It's ok giving youngsters a chance when they're 19/20, 16-18 is a different matter.

Exactly. Our kids are nowhere near ready, most of them anyway.

Or we could have got Tommy Lee back

graeme horne??

promising start, thought we left it a bit late to bring him on

couple of good runs and some good tackles and a decent kick

Thought he would of got more than 20 minutes but did well anyway except for the forward pass, but overall his distribution was fast and accurate. Solid I'd say, as many were tonight.

Thought he did well when he came on.

He did very well tonight and he is large and chunky as well as being quick on his feet. He could prove to be a good signing if even for a short time, Leeds will get a player back better then the one they sent I reckon.

How dare he come to this club, throw crisp, acuurate passes 20 yards out wide from dummy half and expect to get away with it. Send him packing!

Why isn't Agar coaching him ?

Good job, played alright

His distribution was shockingly good, far better than Berro or Houghton. Looks a real prospect. Not sure why Agar only gave him the limited time he did.

He seemed slower at dummy half, taking time to check which way to throw rather than just shipping it out. He did well.

Totally disagree.

Wasn't necessarily a criticism. Just seemed to take his time.

I'd guess he's still a little unfamiliar with our calls etc from the base of the ruck but i thought his distribution was lighting fast and 100% accurate.

Good shout. Hopefully he'll be given more time next week to show again what he can do.

Looks a great prospect. I'd maybe even be tempted to start him and use Houghton off the bench for impact which is his strength imo.

Another week of training will hopefully settle McShane and starting him may be an option. Houghton's speed out of dummy half is great against tiring defenses and should be utilised.

He did well and looks to be a handy short term signing, although I'm not sure what a month training under Agar will do for him.

Very much so made a nice change to see.

I thought he did okay and showed some good touches, will be useful to us whilst Berro is out.

I thought he looked an excellent prospect. Sign him up and put Berro in the centre.

Think Leeds might have something to say on that!

Very stocky aswell, he lined up in defence next to Moa and if it weren't for there skin tones i'd not of known who was who!