hate to say it but the kid isnt a fullback..constantly out of position nervous under the high ball and too many handling errors..

Yep, and add to that hes too skinny and light cant make any impact comming out from under the sticks .
But hes probarbly got the job for week or so untill we get some bodies back !!!

I was certain he would have a good game today to sort out the critics. Don't think he did that badly to be honest, but was shocked how slow he is. Pace was supposed to be his one massive plus, but he clearly does not have it

I didnt think he was too bad tbh, made a mess of one kick but cant remember any other errors. He did alright clearing our line, made a break and did nothing that cost us.

Have to agree he's not even our 3rd choice fullback is he..

McKinnon supposed to be back this week.

I was worried because I haven't seen enough to say he'll make it, but thought he did OK today. Was out of position a little and looked very nervous in parts but he did alright really.

Was awful in the u-20s and wasnt that much better today...constantly out of position,no urgency chasing kicks,No PACE what so ever.

Not a SL player...

He reminded me of Craig Hall, keen as mustard, out of position and couldn't tackle a Sunday dinner. Now Gentle would really amaze me if he makes a SL player out of this lad.

Rather see jack briscoe play there or sharp there and lineham on wing

We both saw his performance against Bradford U20's a few weeks back and we said he was poor then. What he really lacks is desire, he just doesn't seem to have any IMO. I think he does have ability but just doesn't seem to have that inner steel required to succeed at this level.

Sooner have Hall tbh.

I didn't think he did too badly. One glaring error, but other than that he was ok.

Want a damn sight more than what he offerd up from a full-back.

Probably so, but he's a young lad playing his first top level game for ages. He did no worse than any of the other youngsters, in my opinion.

Shocking positional play, one shocking error (I'd forgive him if it was difficult) and offered nothing in attack.

The other youngsters did a damn sight more than Lyne,IMO.

I seem to be in the minority, but I didn't see it like that. Full back is a very difficult position, and he did as well as could be expected.

It's a shame to hear these comments, as he seemed to have real potential when he first broke onto the scene.

[uSome[/u of your fans simply are not happy unless there's a scapegoat, someone to moan about. Usually young lads too, the ones who need supporting the most.

Tommy Lee & Craig Hall both got the same treatment when they were at Hull, Will Sharp got some shocking 'support' last year too.

Not all young players reach their potential though. Tommy Lee was once rated in the top ten teenagers in the world.

And Craig Hall was once rated in the top ten turnstiles.

Unfair level of criticism on here IMO he made one handling error and one loose pass early in the game. What I was a bit disappointed about was that he didn't have the pace to chase down any of the breaks. Sure Hudd have some fast backs but he didn't really gain on anyone chasing back. If he doesn't have the X factor pace I'm not sure what else he will have to make the top level breakthrough.

Not for me. I was accused of not giving the kid a chance but I just do not see the glimpses of ability you need to become a Super League player.

Playing at full back should have given Reece the perfect opportunity to show either a strong running game or a decent pair of hands but he does not show either. Looks timid and clearly doesnt have a rugby brain in attack so unless something radical happens soon I cannot see him making the grade long term.

I hope something radical happens to him soon...

Got some massive hits put on him today, the one from brough was class!

Still is isn't he?




Some shocking comments on here though from so called supporters. It's not exactly Reece Lyne's fault that as a youngster he ran rings around other teams and everyone got excited.