he's binned me on Facebook.......proper thrown his dolly out

I always thought he was a talent.
Serious question as some of you did rate him at one time or another, is his attitude of his own making or down to lack of authority in laying down rules at the club.

Is he bad because or bad because he could?

I don't know whether Kear had trouble with him or not, but since he "lost the dressing room" Thackray's "form" suggests he was probably one of those involved. Peter Sharp got rid of him before his contract was up. Tony Smith then got rid of him before his contract was up. Agar stopped playing him before his contract was up and got rid. He's played for Hunslet,Halifax, Cas, Hull, Leeds, Hull, has been declared bankrupt and has something of a boozy reputation. I don't think you can pin his failure to realise his potential fully on Hull's lax discipline.

I dont believe I mentioned FC's lack of discipline, it was a general synopsis

you implied it with when you refered to hull fans (sone of you did rate him) and then "the club"

You asked whether it down to a lack of laying down the rules at [uthe[/u club, which amounts to the same thing since you're asking the question on our board and he's just left.

You may be correct, but there's evidence that he's a law unto himself wherever he goes and whatever he does, unfortunately.