He's hardly had chance to show any attacking flair, the ball has rarely got out to the centres or wingers in recent seasons. 5 drives and a kick tactics are a back killer !

As far as i am concerned if he has a year left on his contract why are shudds even talking to him, this is a joke and as usual young lads are seeing the bright lights instead of getting there heads down and learning their craft. Just ask jay pitts.

Not bad at all - worked hard and put in some good stints. Not sure that we need him now though, particularly given the dip in form since returning to Shudds.

I tend to agree with other posters who've said that if Shudds want Murphy, we should make them pay what we think he's worth, not accept another bunch of cast-offs; of whom, Raleigh is ok - the other two are probably surplus to requirements.

re: Raleigh
Agar asked to talk to him, because he wants him, he would be a starter for the Wildcats, not a squad player. Giants dont need him to leave.

That's hardly surprising because the only out and out Prop Forwards we have signed up for next season are Higgins & Hickey.

but he isnt a prop? he's a back rower filling in as the giants let jackson and sculthorpe go and never replaced them. If he joins i'm sure it would be as a back row/loose and prop IF needed. However teams now seem to use a loose as an extra prop so he may be doing the same job, but with a different name!!

Walter...?????

Chopper

Gumball

How are Kirmond and Raleigh squad players. They may be at Hudds but lets not kid ourselves they will be first on the team sheet for us.

Not having a pop at you in particular but when did we become Brisbane Broncos - one day maybe but not for a while.

Kirmond was one of our best players when he came to us. Seem to remember when he went back his first game back for shudds was against Wolves in playoffs which they won and him and Broughy ripped it up.

I have it on very good authority ie from the player himself that he wants to stay at Trinity if Agar wants him.

Lets hope that is the case.

Interesting, every one has it on good authority, hope its right

Why wouldnt agar want him? Hope its right

I agree but i was first to post on here that Pryce was going to Catalans and Kear to Batley...that is what he has said...i can only go on that......If he has his head turned by his agent or Agar doesnt want him then obviously that changes things.

The lad has shown earlier in the season his commitment to Trinity so things in theory should not change.

He might want him, but he may want a prop/second row/halfback etc more
cake and eat it etc

I know what you mean but i dont see the need to get rid of one of our first choice backs for the sake of another second rower which were not short of. Props at a push and deffo a half back but a half back of quality or atleast one better than what we have doesnt appear to be on offer from hudds

Murphy gone...4 year deal DONE...Kirkmond and Raleigh coming our way

4 year deal at the giants...DONE..Kirkmond and Raleigh coming this way

You sure about that?

Real shame for the club to lose Murphy. Defensively sound and, when given the opportunity, is an excellent finisher.

well if this is true Im thoroughly peed off. Why would this be a good deal for us?!

Does this need another thread? I could understand if there was a link.

last time you spoke to murphy



grow up