Well, I suppose it's all about opinions - but some wild suggestions on here.

Chris Riley
Matt King
Sean O'Laughlin
Eaorl Crabtree
Stuart Fielden
Ricki Sherrife
Tim Smith

All crazy suggestions, the majority of whom (In my opinions of course) would have a real good chance of getting into our 17........ I can honestly say I would have every single one of them at BV. If you where nominating over rated, or worst value for money then you would have a point.

Mathers plays fullback mate

'"

tries to

Ricky bibey- how he plays in sl is beyond me
Peter lupton- very poor player not worthy of a team in the comp
Mick nanyn- dont know if he has played sl yet but he's got a contract which is frightening to say the least

Good shout, How Henderson has played Super league for 3 or 4 years is laughable.

So no mention of the stirling work he has done this season.

Outstanding in the games he has played thus far - admittedly a long way to go, but all he can do is try and keep that level going - and from what I hear that is his stated intention!

i arn't one for slagging our players off tbh but if you went one seasons gone by hedo n bibey would be candiadates for this i hate to say, this season however hendo appears to have upped his game and all credit to him, and bibey against warrington had inmho ne of his best games in a wakey shirt long may this continue chaps

oh i don't rate calderwood neva have has pace but cant tackle n crap undr high bomb, just my opinion tho

JK rates the lad, so its a toss up between your opinion and JK's.

I doubt you have ever seen him play - stop being a sheep mate and just going along with the opinions of others on here and the demented twitterings of some Saints fans. Bibey is no world beater I accept but he is a far better player than most of his critics ever were, will be or could be.

Did you watch last weeks game, Bibey was the best prop on the pitch

To be fair he has been dreadful the last few seasons especially when he has been used as a centre. I rarely question JK but this MUST NEVER happen again.



As a battering ram and a tackling machine this year so far Hendo is worth his place. So long as he realises that is his job and he no longer has those brain explosions when he momentarily considers himself a creative player I'm happy to have him.

If I ever see him play centre again I may well have to turn and face away from the pitch during the time he is on. I'm getting old and my ticker ain't what it was

100% agreed - but he has found a new lease in the second row this year and, IMO, has stood into the shoes that Big Dunc wore for us. He has said that he aims to be the best second row at the club and backed himself when the opportunity arose to move to Fev. That'a a really positive sign for me!



But NO, No, no to the centres!

Clayton from Cas was the poorest player I've seen in a long while. Don't know if he's still there.

Michael Platt

Way off the mark, you cant have seen much of him, a real grafter, good support player( 7 tries last season, which aint bad for a forward in the bottom team) and versatile. Cas would have kept him but celtic threw alot of money his way.

Yeah he is, though he is unlikely to play for us again unless we have a major injury crisis. At NL level he looked quite good (got in the dream team) but never did much in sl, having said that he only played half a season and his shoulder was bust for half of that.

Even with a busted shoulder he was still a far better player for us last year than korki, moore and halbrecht.

Ian Sibbit imo

No

Matt King by a mile. For what he's on you could buy an entire pack!

£ for £ i would agree.


But you still coudn't buy Fielden

Whose not worth what Kings on!

I always put Graham Horne down as my nomination for this award BUT I thought he was outstanding for Hull v Shudds yesterday. Best game I've seen him play.

A Dobbin who enhanced (in a negative way) his reputation last night was David Hodgson. Had another stinker last night. He gets my vote.

Penny he is dire
The worste ever SL player IMO must go to Wayne Macdonald whatever happened to him?

Kevin Penny

That long streak of from Gateshead/FC who payed in the pack for years would run him close, was it Paul Nicholas? Another one who needed to go see the Wizard.