When he first came to England, Sam was touted as Whitehaven's classy half-back signing. Players become what coaches turn them into, and Saturday shows that. At one point, we had three hookers on the field: Sam, Drew and Latu. When the team was announced, Sam was said to be playing at 6, but as far as I could see, he played his normal game, getting stuck into defence and not really playmaking as a half-back.

George is naturally a centre, and he will become a centre. He has the size for it, and from the snippets I have seen of him, he has the guile for it. I just hope the knee problem was a one-off.

if rooney is fit i think he should be playing. hopefully he will prove the critics on here (of which there are many) wrong

If at anytime you want to enter into a debate between the wife and me feel free to do so. I could do with confusing her a tad





Kear decides the team! What a wonderful concept.


Sam is a hooker and your point is what exactly?

He came from whitehaven as a half back. We bought him as a half back, that is his recognised and preferred posistion.

Silly me I must be missing something here. Is it the same Sam Obst what lived above a chippie in Whitehaven allegedly ofcourse

yep it is , Sam was that good at 7 that he won the division young player and the player off the year hence he used to be 7 when he first arrived

Apologies to you Mutts, and also to mwildcats. I know all about Sam it was an attempt at sarcasm on my part which seems to have gone wrong. Off to chill out

Dont you start. If this carries on to be a 15 page thread it will be your fault

You get confused easy



What is hard to understand about Luke George been a reckognised Winger at the moment. Maybe his future will be in the centre but at the moment he is a winger!

Sam IMO is a lot better at hooker and hope he will play at hooker more than at half back.

Yeah George played centre mmost of the time at Hudds but at Wakey he has been playing at winger, so when I see him in the squad I presume he will be on the wing. Thats why I say he is a reckognised winger at the moment.

No, he's a centre.

Hang on, we've been here before.

Think it might be worth getting Rooney geared up for a return at full back.

But plays on the wing most of the time if not all the time.

So when he plays I expect him to play on the wing.

He is down as a winger on his profile on website

Not sure about confused. I am bored to tears reading about your pathetic attempt at trying to prolong a silly argument about something that had little to do with you in the first place.

yes I do know its a forum and you will have your say whatever. Dont let your vanity take over completely or you will end up looking silly. You have lost another argument accept it and move on.

Keep up at the back adam





Luke IMO is a lot better at centre and hope he will play at centre more than on the wing

Lets just leave it at that shall we. If you want to carry this silly thing on do it by pm.

Seem to remember Toppo started in the first team on the wing.

So did that make him a winger too.

Why can't I get involved? So next time I agree with someone shall I not post anything?

Not lost anything lad.

You have lost me.

At the moment George is a winger - fact

In the future he may play in the centre. Most centres seem to play wing to start with.......

Call it 6th sense if you like, but you just know that a 9 page thread on the squad for Harelquins has to involve some kind of "you calling my pint a puff" type argument.

I can't wait till we announce the team....

So he is a centre

When he was at Hudds academy he played centre

BUT

I am saying when I see him down on the team sheet I presume he will play wing as he has played most if not all games in SL on the wing.

On his player profile he is down as a winger

What a crap thread, thats 10 mins of my life i will never get back.

Cheers