French and Davies

v Woods and Kear


NO contest

Amateur v Profesional..

Couldn't agree more!

French should be pensioned-off, but not at our expense and Davis is a so-called 'expert' on everything rugby!

Why hasn't anyone mentioned Gobbie Paul?

French can always be relied upon to raise a smile. Today he said that the place was full of Catalan's "green and gold" flags before correcting himself and saying "yellow and gold"

tbf i think kear carried the whole commentary team and truly think that this guy will never be out of work.
all of his calls are correct and in tune with the game.



and hes OURS

Wigan Vs Saints

Totally agree with you there, Muts. His knowledge of and enthusiasm for the game always shine through. He explains the important passages of play in the game in a way that really adds to your enjoyment. The kind of commentator who could keep you watching if Saints were playing London Scholars and winning 100-0 at half time. Quality job, Mr. Kear!

I just hope his current day job means he has other, more pressing commitments on cup final day.

is it me just being hopelessly optimistic or does uncle ray not being given the top of the bill game mean he's being phased out




or did he and jonathan 'that was just poor defence' davies just fancy a weekend in the south of france??

French is poor but he has got a great commentary voice.

indeed. whereas davies brings absolutely nothing to the table except welshness; (a negative)

tut tut.

I don't mind Welshness (as long as they're not burning down my holiday cottage), but surely to God there must be someone else in Wales capable of making a better fist of a match commentary than this guy. He had star appeal when he retired from the game, but his time was up long ago, IMO.

no kidding.


Carefull you'll upset Pilchard, he won't have a bad word said about the Welsh. It is time to replace him but with who is the question.

Replace Pilchard?

No not Pilchard

What if we got Pilchard the BBC gig and replaced him with Jonathon Davis? Just a thought....

all i can say is John, Sensational

that would work out, i think

Who is it who keeps calling JD "Jason Dimitri"? He needs sacking, whoever it is.

Oh, and another thing - is it Danny Buderus or Danny Buderus?

Spot on, fake a welsh accent and the job is for you

Who else will confirm a players weight and former amateur/Junior club for us?

if the bbc wont a summeriser liked by the kick and chase lot look no further than shaun edwards a great r.l. player who should still be connected to our great game

Who also has a Welsh (don't forget the capital letter, it is afterall respectful) connection. And very nice it is, boyo, bach, look-you.

Thought Kear's commentry was outstanding on Sunday, hope to see much more!

Forget Mr Pringle and Paul Cullen!