Salford fans are slagging TS off left right n centre and are saying they'd let him go in favour of recalling Sneyd from Cas.

If Salford paid part of his wage would Trinity fans want him back?

Can he play fullback



Not unless Salfford payed all is wages, don't need another tackle shirker we have enough already.

Agar is already lost trying to play all the pivot players we got at the moment without another to add to the mix. Mind you it would allow him to use the gelling excuse for a while longer so you never know!

Not the type of player we need at all right now!

Was great for us the year we made the play-offs but so inconsistent last year playing 1 good followed by 4 or 5 bad......masterstroke from MC to get what he did....and dare I say it....a bit of credit to Agar for getting the best out of him when he did which will have played a part in getting the 90k or whatever it was....

I was a real fan of Smith but I said straight away that Salford wasn't the right place for him.
We have replaced him now. Him and Godinet might have been a good partnership to be honest with better ball from McShane too but we have Sammut and Siejka now so no point.

No. I think in the long run sammut offers more, although very hit and miss at the moment

I would have Amor back

Personally no, I wouldn't. Can't see who'd run off him in the current team. Maybe Kirmond when back to fitness?

I'm surprised Salford haven't recalled Sneyd already to be honest.

Rangi deal. Who knows maybe Sneyd might not want to go back?

One of the most overrated players to ever wear the Wakey shirt. Played ok one in six games for us (at best) then went missing. Fantastic business to get rid for the Money we got. I would have driven him to Salford myself.

There is a reason that he is getting slagged off by the Salford fans.......... He is a below average player

No.

He was never going to work alongside Chase - he looked best for us when partnered with Sykes; a steady, organising SO who could kick in play. Smith has some lovely skills, but he does not guide a team around the park.

Re Marc Sneyd ,I might be wrong but I don't think there's a recall option on the loan deal, it was for the full season as part of letting Rangi go.

Delboy66(aye of the tigers website)

I liked Smith, think he got some unfair stick but this thread is the reason I'm happy we cashed in on him.
If we had kept hold of him, it would be Wake fans complaining that we should have sold him when we had the chance.
He can't win either way!

Mariano coming back to Trinity or Shane Tronc coming out of retirement (if he's out of prison yet) would be better.

I don't think we should bring him back, he'd be no use playing behind this pack at the moment. Saying that, Kirmond does not look like the same player since Smith left.

Hes carrying a injury but I agree, Tim Smith gave him ball in space with time.

Noooooo!!! Erratic, error strewn and immensely over-rated...welcom to the dawn of reality Salford fans, I would spend every penny we have paying Agar off

Timmy has a great rugby mind & whilst I thoroughly enjoyed his time here, his sale to Salford was totally justified.

He’s a luxury player we can ill afford.

Sammut is being neutered by Agar and his mad world of merri-go-round

CORRECT....

We are now having a go at former players are some of you that desparate to find new topics to be negative about. I wonder how long it will be before some of you bring this thread back to sack the coach.

Below regarding Tronc...

In the Townsville Magistrates Court on Wednesday, Tronc pleaded guilty to the offence and was fined $1000.
No conviction was recorded.
The former Brisbane Broncos and North Queensland prop retired last year after succumbing to a recurring neck injury.

brings a smile reading this thread

It was a genuine question rather than an invite to rip him to bits!