Nail on the head with that one!

The best pundits for me are the ones that aren't on as often (with the exception of McManaman who I think is pretty good) - Souness is always sound and knowledgeable and David Platt also knows what he's on about.

I full agree r.e Souness, I actually think Jamie Carragher did a good job at the Man United v Chelsea game.

I agree, you'd get lynched for this is certain places, but if you can get past the accent, he does talk sense.

did you ever actually watch redknapp play?

your extremely profound statement about him being a nothing footballer is about as ridiculous as saying ronaldo doesn't dive....................

the lads career was wrecked by injury but he still proved to be an international quality mid fielder.

I like seeing him on TV because it prompts me to think about his wife.

Amazingly, Robbie Savage is pretty damn good as a pundit. Jimmy Armfield still es on them all though.

Obsessed.

totally agree louise is the stuff of fantasies




also agree about jimmy armfield, he was an excellent reader of the game who always gave a totally unbiased view.

That's the only good thing about Jamie 'To be fair' Redknapp as a pundit.

In terms of insight, he's awful. In fact, I'd rather hear his missus's views* on football because Jamie Redknapp is clueless. This isn't a Liverpool thing - as noted above, Carragher is excellent on TV. Apparently he is an absolute boffin on football and it shows.

*preferably as she is wearing dirty underwear.

Interesting that they've been 'requested to withdraw that picture'. I suspect it's genuine. I hope it is - it's camp as a row of tents and those hoolies will look like tvvats more than they usually do.

Yes, yes I did. He was average. In fact, I would go so far to suggest that his career progression has been more down to daddy than any talent he had.

It was having players like Redknapp playing week in week out that saw Liverpool fall behind United in the 90s.

And playing in some of the worst Ingerlund sides of the past 30 years does not make you international quality.

no mate is was actually having a manager like roy (i've scoured europe for a centre back) evans who brought in such world beaters as bjorn tore kvarme.....................

Friedel's red card has been rescinded.

There's a surprise.

Correct decision.

I think the penalty was harsh as Torres ran straight into him, Friedel didn't make any attempt to bring him down.

He'll be fired up for his usual good game against Nited then...the annoying bald prick has had teflon fingers the past few weeks but will turn into a modern-day Dino Zoff yet again no doubts...but to be fair he shouldn't have been sent off for that incident...if he'd been sent off for being utterly gash then that would have been fair but then Villa would have only been left with about 4 players on the field in that case, and that's being generous!

I just wish we had the option of you on commentary, Keith.

It'd be worth more than £12.99 a month and no swear filters.

you and mark on fanzone next united - liverpool game.

Redknapp is a nauseating, wide-boy who cannot manage to put together a coherent sentence. I refuse to listen to the half-time coments when he is on SKY. Does he still fawn over everything Chelsea and refuse to criticise Jt and F?





Change of topic:

George McCartney has his red card rescinded. What nonsense. It was a sending-off and should have stood. We had this earlier this season when Beye's red card was rescinded - no doubt it was out of sympathy for someone who does not have the technique to tackle

You crack me up.

We scored 4 with him in net and only 1 when he went off.

As well as the team his daddy has decided to become manager of that month.

You're the opposite of United though.

We make players and teams have their best games of the season. Playing you makes the opposition lay down and allow themselves to be walked over to give you a chance of making the title race / European chase interesting.

Does the concept of time escape you?

Agree with that, plus he has an annoying accent.