He kicked the ball after dirty maguire elbowed him so jog on and moan some were else

Thug.

Disgusting act from Joel Tomkins and should think a 3 match ban will follow.

Alibert "You aren't allowed to push with the knee"

Clarke " there wasn't a lot of force in the kick"

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

I can see where it looked like McGuire "might" have bit him, but when JT is pulled up I'm sure he says something like "he hit me in the face", no mention of a bite.

Wonder if he'll be done for kicking or kneeing?

People in glass houses and all that!!!!

2 match ban same as Keith Mason.

Carl Ablett = Thug!

Oh yeah, think it was in the 59th min, by the way.

Have to say Phil Clarke embarrassed himself last night with what can only be described as ridiculously biased views. Tomkins connected with an illegal knee/kick on McGuire and frankly, the 'hardness' of the impact is irrelevant.

Yet when Mason 'stamped' on Fielden's ankle the hardness was relevant? Jeez some people on here dont half talk rubbish.

Wrong again. If you notice Clarke was criticising Tomkins for holding down players and he also said that Donald wasnt late on Richards. But dont let the facts get in the way

3 match ban?!?! I'll have what you're on

After watching Tomkins try using McGuire for drop goal practice thats laughable

And that is blatently overly melodramatic.

As is some of your fans defence of the penalty machine Joel Tomkins



At least Ablett's "tackle" was during play and not a snide boot on a grounded player.

Just read back at some of your fans defence of Ablett before you want to come and have a go!

Tomkins makes minimal contact, Ablett's was a forearm in the face, but dont let that get in the way.

I can only state my point of view and can you really defend Tomkins actions from yesterday?

Minimal contact ah right so its ok to try and boot someone then as long as you dont quite get it right???

Show me where I have defended him, please, go on.......

Wow you are thick. Find me anywhere where I have said that its ok to try and boot someone, I said he made minimal contact which in Tomkins case will work in his favour. The fact that the intent was there wont, as it was a very stupid thing to do.

I seem remember when Mason stamped on Fielden's foot everyone saying 'oh get over it, he has just stepped on his foot'. IMO both occasions are the same.

Just noticed post above, seems making falso claims is your thing

Looking at Leeds site, Joel just a caution,

[urlhttp://www.therhinos.co.uk/news/14905.php[/url

As you eluded to on another thread........how Leeds fans defended Ablett then the same goes for Tomkins?

As much as Ablett was punished I would think any fair minded RL supporter would say Tomkins actions were unacceptable and he should face the disciplinary panel?

Nope it was the hypocricy AGAIN of you lot coming on here having a go, when *most* of us have already condemned JT, whilst forgetting that after the Ablett incident most of you lot neglected to do the same!

No not at all.......I am telling YOU he tried to boot McGuire......as he certainly did.......were you not watching the game?

As for Mason I agree there is no place for that in sport and as much as I am not a fan of Fielden it was bang out of order!