I think it was the signing of Ned Catic

Will their be some sort of replay of all the Challenege Cup games for this weekend games? cant remember whether or not their was.

How did Tim Smith play? Did he partner Sam or Tommy when on the field?

How did he do it attack and defense?

I have never saw a player more clueless with ball in hand than tim smith yesterday

He often got caught with the ball too much.

I'm not sure whether that was his fault or those around him. On a couple of occaisons he kicked us out of trouble but overall he didn't make a big impact.

Not good then!

Who did he partner in the halves?

Tomkins & Tommy went to hooker.

Sam ended up at full back?

Sam at first the Tommy when Sam went to fullback. He had a very poor game but must say it was a great day out big Thank You to all the barrow fans for a great day out and hats off to there team for a very determined performance

How did Sam do at FB?

So disappointed in Tim, I had high expectations for him for this season.

Sam actually did alright, caught everything what come at him and seemed to make a few good yards when he had ball in hand. Okay, he caught more yesterday at full back than Mathers has in the 2 years he's been here.

And as did I regarding Tim Smith, its just not working for him though.

How did Riddell play?

Someone else I've been disappointed with this season so far. And Roberts?

I thought Riddell did ok.

However, for Riddell to stand out for the short time he is on the pitch, he must take on the defence alot more. He did so on a couple of occaisions in the first half and made a couple of half breaks.

He should have done better with the pass to Leuluai when he broke in the second half, but to make the brake in the first place was good going.

Roberts? Play well? Do anything against a weak side?

Was quite amusing when he did that poor pass to Tommy, he turned round with his hands on his head, only to realise he had to make an instant tackle when he realised a Barrow player was about to storm past him.

He played at fullback and had a safe game.

After seeing Mathers playing at fullback you appreciate positioning and ability to sweep up behind the backline and I think Roberts does this very well.

One of my only criticisms of Roberts is that when he returns/scoots, he doesn't look beyond the defender and will run at the player instead of looking to exploit a gap.

Me and my mate were laughing at that, Piggy made a great break, had about 4 men supporting him - missed them all with his pass, then turned round and if it wasnt for the "TURNNNNNNNNN", the Barrow player would of gone straight past him, and most probably scored.

I expect Roberts and Riddell to stand up and be counted against Saints this week.

They are both experienced and should be reasonably settled now in the country and with the team.

But why do I feel it's more likely to be Sam and Ainscough who will be more of a threat.

He passed okay, he showed he had a sidestep but he can't run. If he could run, he would be class. He even looks a bit strange when he is walking. He was always pointing and telling players where to run.
Barrow looked better coached than Wigan with dummy runners confusing us. Their half-backs were electric.

Barrow's 70 yard first try started with a forward pass right in front of me...it was at an angle of about 30 degrees and should have been spotted but I have no complaints about the ref. He had a decent game. Wigan did forward passes as well that he missed.
I suppose he didn't have a decent game in that case. I suppose what I mean is that he didn't seem to favour one side.

Richards tends to do the same when playing at full back.

Can't comment on the alleged forward pass but by heck that James Nixon can shift - Absolutely skinned S Tomkins





That alleged forward pass was nowhere near as obvious as Karl Pryce playing basketball when he attempted to put the ball down late on - Now that was a bad decision !

Dont know if this has been mentioned elsewhere as I have only just got back from sunny Cumbria but the only positives for me were the performances of Carmont and Ainscough.

The try Ainscough scored in the first half in the corner when he jinked past 2 Barrow players in the corner was absolutely superb.

Hope the young lad scores a few on Thursday!!

If Wigan are going to win on thursday he will be our man to score some tries along with Gleeson

Yes I wondered what the hell was going on as well.

The PA system was befitting of the Knowsley Road stadium.