Obtuse? you mean like one of your own posters saying the games should be played in rugby stadiums,correct me if im wrong but isnt the stadium you play in a football stadium.

no its a dual purpose

Nice that you filled your corners in at your ground with seats, you just need ass's on them now...

With pleasure. You're wrong.

No disrespect to Hudds or Leeds but I and many other fans this side of the Pennines would love to see a Wire Wigan final. Over the past
two or three seasons I feel we've been the top two overall.

Please its a football stadium first and foremost get over yourselves ,dual purpose my harris,last week you was in near tears over wether you would be able to play saints there.

Please keep writing Leeds off....brings back great memories of the play=offs last year

Not as nice as the memories of the Challenge Cup though

Both semis should be great games

Doesn't matter who was pulled out first for the venues.

planning was granted as dual purpose, both sports are played their and both teams colours are in the seasts...

The stadium was built for the use of both clubs. And that's the legality of it. It's not a fantasy.

There is no rule saying that Wigan cannot play there 24 hours prior to Latics playing there.

The uncertainty was down to one man being awkward. It took a couple of days before he would confront the reality of the situation.

Hence, the Wigan game went ahead as planned.

It will likely be the same outcome next time such a 'clash' arises.

Stop living in hope that sometime in the near future the club you fear the most will suddenly be made homeless. They won't.

i can't believe that you have said that Yed?



2 cracking semi finals in store and i think that any of the last 4 could get to the final and produce a great final,i'm not bothered at all where our semi against wigan is played as it clearly has no effect on the result,it's only a piece of grass

A pitch does make a difference, not the grass itself, or in Leeds case the sand but the dimensions are different.

Well I enjoyed the Challenge Cup last season, because we were written off, and in that game and the play-offs following, we proved how stupid that was

. It was the catalyst for our season, so I don't think we did too badly out of it

If we had the choice, Leeds would have been the pick. Lowest ranked team at the moment, but we will have to perform better then we did v Saints.

Why not play it at Salford

Only 10k capacity.

Leeds v Wigan, the 2 clubs with the greatest attendances over the last few years......... can see this as being one of the best attended semis for a few years

God they do moan over on their board don't they

Can't handle the fact they're the worst team left in the draw, and the fact we'd rather play them than two teams we haven't beaten this year....

Strange people

Good draw, can't remember the last time we played them in a CC semi. Should be a classic.

1968 at Swinton, it was my 3rd game i attended with my grandad....i was 5 .......we lost

When we put you out, will that prove that you were actually the worst team left in the draw?

If you're still six places below us in the table then no.



As things are, you are the lowest ranked contenders remaining in the competition. The only way to change that is to start winning games more reguarlarly. Oh, and for your coach and captain to start working together.

This has no bearing on the semi finals as it is a one-off cup match. You or the Wolves could have one every league match last season yet still didn't even make it to Old Trafford. You must have been utterly embarrassed to see us and Saints reach the final - yet again. Who gives a stuff about your league form when it's trophies in the cabinet that are a measure of true success.

I think it will be a Wigan v Hudds final. The Wolves have had their best season form wise and are not a patch on last year. If I were you then I'd have certainly wanted Leeds in the semi, but don't count your chickens just yet...