He is quick, thats about it.

Madge obviously fancies him overly Charnley, but with either in the centre we are alot weaker in that position than last season.

We need to settle on a 17 and stick with it.

we must have two marshes in this wigan team cause the marsh I have watched is a defensive liability, never passes the ball and seems to have problems catching it as well.

Not SL quality in my humble opinion.



he is very quick though.

you must be right because the stefan marsh who plays for wigan is quite a good defensive centre!!

The "defensive liability" who made 2 great tackles in a row on our own line, another that stopped a break and forced the winger in touch and was the only player within 10m for both interception tries, despite having to run further than anyone else?

But the problem is Wigan fans keep expecting a 20 year old who has played 14 first team games to slot in at centre and automatically be a 100% replacement for Martin Gleeson who has played over 300 matches + test matches, played in a few finals etc etc etc. The lack of patience in some fans staggers me. I mean 14 games into the lads career and you and others have written him off totally not just as a Wigan player but as a Super League player. I find it unbelievable! Give the lad a chance!

spot on thats some of the reasons i give him M.O.M and no 1 else stood out in that game for me .

His defence was shakey when he first broke into the first team but he has improved with it massively. Wigan fans just see him once and assume thats how he plays all the time. He has been gradually improving with each match he plays.

Good for him.

He tried hard on Friday I though he was one of the better performers along with S Tomkins and Mossop. The pack were well and truly hammered. I was sat near the dug out and the size difference in the Catalans bench and ours was obvious.

Henderson, Menzies, Sa and Dureau had a field day. Watching Henderson control the game showed that McClorum is not effective enough to be playing so many minutes.