Game set match Phuzzy?

there lies the weakness in your argument dear boy!! you have the wrong poster. i never said that i think it might have been DISA

be a bit more thorough mate

jjb got an england call up for the world cup after 4 games back from a half season injury, which isnt bad going really.

The argument is the one you clearly lost. Selective memory I see. Figures.

well it would be if he had the right person fnar fnar

And look what good that did!!


Hock was great for you against bradford but as yet he's to prove his worth over a full season IF he could do that and keep his head straight then you would have a debateable point re-him v ali and jjb.
I think Hock had/has the potential but not the consistency or temprement.
Maybe this season he will prove any doubter's wrong but 4 games into the season i'd still take Ali and Jjb over him any day of the week.

mate whats your problem the argument about coaches and all that was another poster not me!! i just felt ablett was a little better than a pie fans left nut.

we had got this thread back on track until you you turned ya XBOX off

Which you agreed with. Be a bit less selective with what you remember mate. Remember the Leuleui argument or shall I remind you?



Not bad at all. Still doesn't negate the fact that our backrowers are all international first choices. Plainly your arguents hold as much water as a Tim Smith Scotch!

True but neither do your backs without barrett!!

But now S Tomkins is here

You're an idiot. I'm a father of 2 who's been watching Wigan for 20+ years. I've tried to ignore your purile insults thinking you might actually have a brain buried somewhere under that Leeds bias and ignorance. Sorry, I was mistaken.

But now we have Sam



Or do you not rate him either?

Cue another pointless argument

He is mate and he looks the buisness but the rest of the league will know about him now plus he hasn't been put under a lot of pressure yet

So you dont think he can hack it?

I do rate the lad but now the other teams know what to expect and this week is a big step up in class from that pile o pooh you destroyed last week.
FWIW what i've seen of him he does look quality but don't you fickle wigan lot start getting on his case when the team aren't performing or don't win a trophy

You haven't read many Sam Tomkins threads on here before then

It doesn't matter what good they did. The fact that he chose them is all that matters re: this argument. Otherwise you have to say the same for all the Leeds players who featured. Let's start with JJB, Sinfield, Peacock, McGuire, Burrows, Senior...You want me to go on?

I never said that


This week is another step up for him,he will meet a completely different challenge and quality of opponent.
Even if he doesn't play well it doesn't mean i don't rate him but don't get giddy and hail him the saviour of wigan and england RL just yet!
The early signs are very good but don't put too much expectation the lad.

yes im sure! about a great many things

come on mate keep a lid on it! insults are not the way to go. you have to keep as scence of humour!! its the day before your coaches biggest game of the season. its good too see you pie's reved up you were all suicidle 2 weeks ago

ps plenty of people with kids play XBOX(some of us have PS3 too)

right fuzz nice chatting!! im oft down pub with my dad to do the quizz enjoy it tomoz

may the best team win!!

Go on and on if you want mate it doesn't alter the fact that hock still isn't consistent over a full season or that i would pick Ali or Jjb before him






Did the leeds players cover themselves in glory in the world cup???
My answer to that is did anybody in the england squad really perform to their potetial=NO.
You stated that the national coach picked hock over jjb to support your argument and i merely pointed out that it didn't do much good!!
We all know wigan fans will pick hock as the better player and the leeds fans will do the same with ali and jjb the big difference is our's have done it in finals and over full seasons hock has yet to do that and even wigan fans in the past have admitted to his flaws and temprement so we'll have to agree to disagree.
Enjoy the game.

If he does play well and we win, then he will of proved he can cut it in super league. We will seeif he can do it consistantly after that.

No just the one. That you are an idiot. Don't go taking continuous pops at someone and then when you've been shown up pretend you didn't mean it! You clearly thought I was a kid, so don't give me the plenty of people play with an X Box bollox! I tried to ignore your purile insults but you weren't having any.

"Insults aren't the way to go"? Isn't it funny how it's always the ones who think they should be able to use them without reply who come out with that argument...

Cannot believe this, I ask the question on like page 7 how many Wigan players would get into the Leeds team for friday.

Boy did I open a can of worms.

I don't doubt that fella.
I think he can but with the young guns we all know there'll be peaks and trough's i was merely pointing out tmw night will be his 1st real major test and even if he doesn't play well i still reckon he's got a great future.
The same with young watkins and mcshane at our place they will make mistakes but i still think there's a new breed of quality across some clubs ready to step up.