He would be ok if he did a few squats in the off season to bulk up his legs. He is an average player and out of his depth at Wigan, he looked a decent player at Salford and in the first half of last year he did ok but he should have put some size on in the off season if he is to play prop this year.

his work rate is decent dont know why everyone fails to notice this. last year his stats were much better than other higher paid players. and if you want an honest opinion why asked these biased coley haters. He offered nothing in attack but safe and sound in defense and i think there are bigger problems at the club than coley. best prop was feka , then o'carrol then coley then fielden last friday.

Hes a penalty machine

Misses more than his fair share of tackles n all

Is he really that good?

Seriously though he gives away too many pens he makes lots of tackles but misses alot as well. He just plods along, he i snot the type of player we need at Wigan.

Horrendous player. we need shut of this mon at the end of the season. truely awful

Give over, Fielden was miles ahead of Coley on Friday night and he had a quiet game by his standards.

We should drop him untill then and play O'Carroll and Prescott.

He should be nicknamed "the crab" seeing how that is his running style.

Not good enough for us imo.

Dave/Brian,

As two of the better informed on the subject: was Coley's play sufficient to warrant his return to the first team ahead of Prescott?

Coley isn't good enough.
If we are to improve then he's the type who has to be replaced by a better player when his contract is up. That's the end of 2009.
Don't think there's a snowballs chance.......... of him getting another contract.

Really hope he doesn't get a new contract

How many of Noble, Mathers, Phelps, Coley, Bailey, Smith do we expect to get a new contract?

None deserves it but maybe some will get it

And there ends this thread. Truely, no more needs to be said.

Coley is a huge bloke and very fast for a forward of his size but he looks to have a heart the size of a pea!

Not good enough for Wigan but you can understand his heart not quite being in it after being offered to Wakey in the off season.

I remember being shocked when Wigan signed Coley, having seen him play a lot in the NL1 I do not consider him to be a GOOD SL player. He also gives away loads of penalties. I really don't know why Noble took him to Wigan.

cos he used to play well against us nearly every time we played Salford

Because we needed an experienced prop and he was available & affordable.

Signed when we needed a prop to help Fielden out and Prescott and O'Carroll were not mature enough.

They will be next season though so there's no need to renew his contract.

Prescott was one of the water men on Friday and looks like he's buled up in the off season also

Never mind the crab, how about Willow?

Fantastic.

Coley should be in the reserves ready to cover injuries to the other 4 first teamers.

Hahaha



He probably run it in harder then Coley.

aload of crap made 5 yards every time if that ,, only difference this time he had hold of the ball