Slow motion replay certainly made it look worse.

Oh dear dave comeback when your charity case of a team does anything

Ok in that case i hope he broke both

I hope mcguire has broke his leg the cheating ****'"

I'm not sure Donald's challenge was late - was he already committed to the tackle? A 50/50 call.

However, once the penalty for a late challenge on a kicker was given, I believe it should have been where the ball landed. As this was in touch, it should have come 10 metres infield. Notice how keen Bentham was to tell Alibert where the penalty was - ball was moved back a few yards from where Pat had originally placed it!

Not 100% sure of this - I've only reffed schoolboy rugby union matches in the past 25 years. Certainly in union, the penalty would be 15 metres infield for a similar incident.

Having said all that, Wigan did blow it with too many dropped balls etc.

Did we miss Feka? Went into a crucial game once more with only 3 main props and lost a very close game again.

What was that about me editing a post? And calling me a pr!ck?

Idiot.

Tackling somebody without the ball is a foul and that's why Donald was penalised.

Deary me...

I think Donald was commited, Richards appealed the Carmont tackle before setting off down the touchline, potentially crucial seconds.

Yeah went over board there edited it

Maybe McGuire had a delayed reaction from cheap shot Joel Tomkins kicking him on the ground and thats how he injured himself?

Or maybe he picked up his injury rolling around p*ssing himself laughing that Sam Tominks should be considered a safe full back?



Either way - classy that you all hope he is seriously injured



Justice maybe was done yes - Joel Tomkins kicks player in chest whilst on the ground. Joel Tomkins stays on pitch. Player Joel Tomkins kicks, p*sses all the Pie Eaters off by "Cheating" (oh and he also scored a try) -

RESULT

Disgraceful comment , take a leaf from the man in your avatar .

Alibert just doesnt have a clue, he ruined that game for me today and you could clearly see he was frustrating players of both teams.

I've said it before and I'll say it again.. he is only reffing Super League because he is French. If he was from Skem he wouldnt even get a look in reffing NL1 games.

All??

Really????

Made a fool of yourself there didn't you, I saw it before you edited it

Nice edit. You post did say you hope McGuire BROKE HIS NECK?

You do know what thats means dont you? Wonder what the young Harlequins player who broke his neck playing RL, and is now paralysed, thinks of your comment?

How Alibert got that game is a mystery. Still, he didn't cost it us.

Wishing an injury on a player is low though. Weren't we all asking for some guy to be sacked for cheering Amos' injury????

Something all Leeds and Wigan might agree on .

Mabye but i bet you 3000+ people thought the same

Pat Richards bottling kicks cost you the game.

My apologies got caught up in the moment and completely read it wrong. Hence I edited it. Now bugger off to your own board

Apology accepted

Something that does require further discussion imo.