At the moment the only coach we should consider replacing Noble with is Edwards and personally I think the club should pull out all the stops to bring him in; but I've been saying that ever since he left.

I'll be amazed if IL sacks Noble..it will cost him to much.

Edwards is NOT going to happen in the short term. Some need to deal with this.

passion only

I can deal with this, I've been dealing with it since he left. But that wasn't my point in any case.

You can be so condescending.

Oh dear.

Give Noble untill the end of the season to turn it around and get a new contract, if not I would line up Edwards/Hanley with Wane his Assisstant, maybe bring Faz back as under 21s or even Rads.

So in your opinion then unless we can get Edwards Noble is the man for Wigan.

It is not condescending it is fact. Edwards is tied to 2 contracts that we would have to buy out along with his family circumstances.

I as much as anyone would want him at Wigan but it is not an option for at least another 3 or 4 years.

James Lowes

Edards is not an option. I think he'll want to stay with Wales until at least the 2011 Union World Cup.

Hanley is the best option. Available and a proven record.

I do think he will turn it round, Noble will still be our coach at end of season. I want him to blood Tomkins/Mossop, never play Mathers/Coley/Bailey/Phelps/Riddell untill they earn their shirts. Riddell played about 10mins in first half and 10 in second and did absolutely rack all!!!!!!!

Hanley done and dusted apparently!

Riddell is clearly not fit!!!

Yet Noble still selects him, over Tomkins.

Rads was IL's guest tonight (or one of em...) hope he's being offered a role in the coaching staff.

does he hold a coaching badge ?

I think he (along with Farrell and PaulNewlove) was on coaching courses a few years prior to retirement.

is that the reason why he fell in his aRse

And "if" Noble continues to play the player you picked out..do you think he will turn it around then ?

farrel would be my choice due to the trojan type attitude he took on the field

But Farrell has no experience????

I'd go for Cullen. He would get the percentages right, help with winning collisions and just give that extra 'squeeze' necessary around the ruck.

Brian Noble is not the cause of this. We all keep thinking that the players are all prim and proper but my good god! I wont indulge on here but i am not suprised in the slightest that we have won one grand final when we have had good players, all in that last few years.......

As soon as we have players who WANT to play for wigan then we have cracked it. At the moment we have about 6!!!!

Where is this from?

Would be the best option at the moment.

There's a very good coach down the Rd at the LSV