Any thoughts?

Ellery is one name that immediately comes to mind.

No coincidence IMO.

Tactically the Aussie and Kiwi coaches are superior.

I know it's going back a while but in our most successful period we had; Lowe, Monie & West and we cleaned up with silverware. We did have Clarke & McInnes and Murphy before that I know and it can be argued that they set the ball rolling but primarily it's been Aussie & Kiwi coaches that have led us to success.

Our most successful periods in the SL era we had Monie (for the second time), Endacott and Raper.

To be honest, Ellery wouldn't excite me at all. He's not been involved at a serious level in the game for a while. The only Brit I'd even entertain is Edwards, but I'd expert him to have to serve a brief apprenticeship first just to get him up to speed. Anyway there's no possibility of Edwards coming at present, for all the well-known reasons.

For me, it's got to be an Aussie. If possible an NRL man - if not an existing head coach, a promising NRL assistant-coach. Someone who's learned from the best and is just waiting to take charge of a team himself.

i would like to see us lure justin morgan. a fantastic coachwith limited resources at kr, yet with the passion and pride shown are out performing us this year by a mile. on paper we have a very good team, maybe not quite ready to challenge but top 4. the fault for me is how we are coached. the team looks stale under noble anf i think someone like justin who is vocal, tactically sound and recruits very well is what we need. i think he is ready to step up to a big club who need a breath of fresh air to get back to where we should be, somewhere near the top !!!!!

Totally agree on the Ellery front. As a player he was an absolute class act, but even then was prone to 'attitude' issues, which led to him being transfer listed at one time. As a coach, he's not done much in the last 10 years, which would be OK if we had a seasoned, competent, winning squad. At the moment though, we're far from that & we need a top NRL coach in his prime to turn this round.

Speaking of mike...anyone read his book? I have, and I can't believe the stuff Mo and Whelan did to him and his family!

I've not been a fan long enough to know all about it, but I was appauled by how he was treated!

Short answer is no, as much as Wane is Wigan through and through and has paid great service to the club. We might well play with more passion and aggression but passion and aggression doesn't win titles, it doesn't win cups which is what it's ultimately all about. Our best years were when we had Lowe and Monie as coaches, tactically we were untouchable, that's no coincidence. There seems to be a thing around where 'we' as fans need to see a team full of local lads, well therein lies the problem. We've got at our disposal probably the best pool of potential around but recent years has seen an inability for these lads to step up to SL to the right level. Despite having probably the strongest and most consistent youth set up around. I don't think that's a coincidence either. A club like ours needs the best rugby brain at the helm, we won't find those internally.

Alot of people's decision to choose Wane as Noble's successor is mainly due to the fact he's an ex-Wigan player and that he happens to be a well respected Wiganer who happens to be a coach at the club, that's it. Is that really a good enough excuse to employ him as first team coach?

Do those who want Wane as coach know how he coaches, his general tactics and his decision making? I doubt it.

Personally speaking, I'd have Wane as coach for both on and off the pitch reasons. His reserve sides are very entertaining to watch and are generally well desciplined.

Exactly. Wane as assistant by all means, but we need a proven coach who will sort this rabble out.

IMO till the end of the season it’s good enough for me.

We need a top class Aussie coach who can come over with a new attitude, practices and breathe a new lease of life into a team that is low on confidence and form.

However no Aussie coach will come over mid way through the season. It’s unfeasible to think a coach from Australia will be able to get over here and do a proper job for the rest of the season due to the logistics of moving your whole life to the other side of the world.

So what do we do till then? There are zero signs of a recovery at this moment in time and history shows Wigan under BN’s leadership are unable to string together a consistent run of victories.

Hopefully Wayne can come in and with him being a respected ex player he can rub some of his professionalism off onto the players. Even if we get the team playing with pride it will stand us in good stead for next season and hopefully life under a new coach.

To continue down the road we have been doing is not an option imo.

A new presence with fresh ideas is what this club needs with some new backroom staff.

This club is stuck in a rut.

Stephen Kearney hits every single one of those points imo.

Head coach at NZ,

Learnt from the best in Bellamy and Bennett but is still an assistant at Melbourne,

He knows Tommy from his time at NZ so will have a go to guy straight away.

He will play him at 9 too

Agreed, I keep coming back to Lam for some reason, not sure he would apply but would certainly sort out the attack.

Stuart Raper is out of a job at the mo.

That would be an excellent choice.

Thirded!

[iYour reason and your passion are the rudder and the sails of your seafaring soul.

If either your sails or your rudder be broken, you can but toss and drift, or else be held at a standstill in mid-seas.

For reason, ruling alone, is a force confining; and passion, unattended, is a flame that burns to its own destruction.

Therefore let your soul exalt your reason to the height of passion; that it may sing;

And let it direct your passion with reason, that your passion may live through its own daily resurrection, and like the phoenix rise above its own ashes.[/i Kahil Gibran

He would be a good choice, but not sure he could reignite the masses.

Raper, with Lam as assistant. That would do it.

took the words out of my mouth

what is Wane doing at the club now? if he is that good, why is he not having a positive impact on the players - if he is a tactical and motivational genius, that would surely shine through to the team, even with him only being the assistant?

He's not the assistant. He's just the reserve team coach.

John Pendlebury won 'coach of the year' once.

Dave Lyon would make a quality coach and would make you the fittest team in the league!!!!