Edited to show what you meant to say.

Try looking at the records and tell me that they would be poor choices..

I've no issue with Hanley in the slightest even though my choice would be Murphy, Edwards though, no thank you, build one outside the Millennium Stadium for him.

not a matter of dragging it up....more a matter of pointing out to a few people what kind of bloke Shaun is.

i still dont think it should be him though.

I can assure you, I have nothing against shaun edwards. As I say, he is a rugby union coach to me; nothing more. I didn't get my heart broken during the wigan run. I see that as a great acheivement, if cheapened by the circumstances. Edwards- good player in a team of stars! Honest, that is my view.

The only rugby player I don't like is bailey.

If there should be a statue of edwards there are two (maybe 3) places it should be. The first is outside central park. The other is outside the millenium stadium (maybe the DW) seen as only one of those is possible (Mill), I would wite to them. It would be more appropiate.

My view seems to have lined up with yed. Hanley and murphy are both good shouts

Who would you suggest, who isn't a former wigan player?

We must remember there are a thousand rugby league stories at wembley that don't involve wigan (and many are better).

I doubt it.

Double post- f up

Fox missing a kick? Failure over triumph?

Only in England, get a grip.

Winning the World Cup?

I must have missed that one where GB/England won a Rugby League World Cup Final at Wembley??

I agree, a statue of a loser pfftt.

Rugby League's version of Ray Finkle.

Never said it was a heart warming story but it beats 'only pro team buys best players and shockingly wins loads of stuff'

Face it the Murphy story sums up the spirit of rugby league far more than almost anything else.

But Leeds didn't win any major trophies at all when they were the only full-time team, never mind at Wembley.

It has to be a Wigan player and that Wigan player is Shaun Edwards.

Yeah, cause Les Boyd was a carpet fitter when he came over here right?

Fitted my Grans

Martin Offiah ,best try ever scored at the old Wembley....Joel Tomkins scored a better one this yr though

So now his fault is to be in a good team.... Stop making yourself look silly... This is a Wigan board discussing a subject which will inevitably involve OUR big names, and others, which it has. Go back to your own board and have a 3 page discussion about yours...

I don't think you can read.

I won't explain it again.just clarify and summize. Shaun edwards is a rugby union name now.

I will go to an extreme, just for you. No matter what edwards did, he is a rugby union name now! That is incredibley simplistic but you don't seem to understand otherwise.

Many wigan fans say that edwards should be in due to wigan's period of dominance. I am saying that not only is that not in the spirit of rugby leageu but also he is a rugby union name now!

Take your Warrington specs off. Some posters on here are saying that Wigan bought anyone they wanted. They certainly replaced very good/ great players (the likes of Hanley, Gregory, Goodway etc) but Edwards is sixth on the all time Wigans appearance list so obviously they thought he was one of their most influential players EVER. particularly when you look at the players above him are also five of the all time greats of Rugby League. wigan.rlfans.com/fusion_pages/in ... age_id=481 Edwards is the most decorated player EVER in Rugby League He has the most Wembley appearances and Wembley wins (where is the status going to be) I think he was also the youngest ever winning captain. It's not his fault that the RFL are stupid and didn't recognise his value to the game (see the article in Fridays Evening Post)

Take your Warrington specs off. Some posters on here are saying that Wigan bought anyone they wanted. They certainly replaced very good/ great players (the likes of Hanley, Gregory, Goodway etc) but Edwards is sixth on the all time Wigans appearance list so obviously they thought he was one of their most influential players EVER. particularly when you look at the players above him are also five of the all time greats of Rugby League. wigan.rlfans.com/fusion_pages/in ... age_id=481 Edwards is the most decorated player EVER in Rugby League He has the most Wembley appearances and Wembley wins (where is the status going to be) I think he was also the youngest ever winning captain. It's not his fault that the RFL are stupid and didn't recognise his value to the game (see the article in Fridays Evening Post)

I would be very happy indeed if you did not explain again....

What about Richie Mathers, those three try saving tackles he pulled off at Wembley 2010 must be one of the all time great stories of Wembley.

Also being a former Wigan player it keeps the connection with Wigan the most successful team at Wembley.

I think Mathers would be a win-win, accepted by fans of Wigan and Warrington as well as probably Leeds and Cas as well.

then we're both happy.



I would still love to hear a suggestion from you of a player not in a wigan team who deserves a spot.

As I have said Hanley and Murphy are my top two.

Wigan legend and Sts, Leigh and Warrington legend, both GB legends and great ambassadors of the sport.

So who, not a Wigan 'legend', would you put forwards as a suggestion?

Don Fox