Quote ="wigan_knight"I dont think that was Carmont the second try deffo wasnt him.'" It wasn't Carmont, it was Brad Tighe. Carmont has never scored against Wests. www.rleague.com//db/player/c/car ... /index.php This was the game: www.rleague.com/db/content/80000/80985.php

Quote ="wigan_knight"I dont think that was Carmont the second try deffo wasnt him.'" It wasn't Carmont, it was Brad Tighe. Carmont has never scored against Wests. www.rleague.com//db/player/c/car ... /index.php This was the game: www.rleague.com/db/content/80000/80985.php

Carmont is meant to be a good defensive centre. Do you think they will put him alongside Calderwood, and if Goulding is to be our other centre he will line up alongside Richards?

I know all clubs have stop-gap sorts of players around, and I understand that at present Wigan have few alternatives in the juniors, so as an individual signing I wouldn't bag it too much.

But seriously the sooner EVERYONE can stop signing players like Carmont (unwanted in the NRL for a reason) and instead play younger players the better. Carmont may be vaguely superior at the moment, but a half decent 18-year old should overtake him in ability TBH.

BTW I'm not particularly having a go at Wigan or Carmont. At Leeds there are a couple of players who if enough juniors were being produced wouldn't be playing SL either.

Everyone dont listen to tricky he's named every player going





I called it

I think you'll find that it was I that posted it on here before you KP

I called it not you...My mother has the proof....

And that is were things in common ends between these two Aussies. The bloke is not fit to lace Jamie Lyons boots.

would just like to say to all those who mocked me when i said we would defo get a centre, eat them words!

were is where, and Carmont is not an Aussie.

I just spotted that also.

Hogan could have scored that on his crutches !

looks decent off one try??



think this one should be put to bed and lets all wait and see !

I specialise in 5 yard bardge overs

Hmmm that's doubled in distance

Speaking of tries, have you scored this year ?

If I've told you once, I've told you a dozen times - I'm a provider not a finisher

You qualify for one of your famous forfeits.

I've re-drafted the club constitution to include kicks

If you read my other post i say i dont believe the tries in question was him. But if it was he looks decent. i was refering to the 2 trys from 3min 30 secs

Played well in the Samoa-Lebanon game and provided a great inside ball out of the tackle for his winger to score. Also has a good try average in the NRL apparently and universally acknowledged as being strong defensively. I think he'll do alright for us.

Just as an aside, surely the likes of Trent Barrett, Feka etc. who have played against him recently in the NRL will have good knowledge of him as a player. You would think that opinions would have been sought before signing him....

That pass must have been a fluke, my nephew played outside him for 3 years and never once got a decent pass. One of the worst centres i've ever seen, poor defensively and often caught out of position.

I'd be inclined to take this opinion seriously, if we hadn't had loads of similar posts from people Down Under when we signed Trent Barratt.

I still remember them now: "I have it on good authority that Barratt is crocked." "I watch Barratt every week, and he's finished." "Barratt's not the player he was, he's lost all his pace." "My brother played with Barratt for many years, and reckons he was always overrated."

Forgive us if we don't automatically deduce that you're telling the truth.

Nobody mocked you for saying we'd get a centre, we mocked you for saying it as if you were breaking important news to us or something. About 200 people said we needed a centre and most of them knew we were going to get one before you broke the transfer news of the century to us

This signing has rocked superleague.