this was an excellent win well done to all the players for a team effort.by the way who said tim smith had gone home.

customs ? airport security ?

don't be silly.are you

smith was presenting the awards at half time.

They commented on GMR that whether we played well or not the team spirit on display was magnificent, and lets be honest sometimes when your not at your best team spirit can get you through.

great win mate
we need to carry this win forward into our next game (bulls)

thought coley and prescott led well from the front gave us a good platform to work from

That was the pleasing aspect of tonights game.
Effort from 1 -16

I'm glad we don't have to play them again this season. They are the roughest, toughest team in the game.

Who was 17?

take it you're omitting stand-off Pryce. Seriously when I saw them warming up and Pryce was running at stand-off I panicked and thought this has to be a joke. Unfortunately it wasn't, good job he got injured!

your not wrong there mate ,,,, i thought us fans were awsome tonight i think we got the boys through the last 20 mins mind u think bent thaler got us all going so that was the only thing he got right tonight thanks mr benT thaler

Karl Pryce.

Awful, awful awful! Does not look at all interested. SO much potential but so little effort.

Well on the bright side it'll let people tell us how great he looks in the reserves.

Great commitment from the lads tonight, didnt really play well but they stuck at it in what was at times a testing environment.

Im getting serioulsy sick of the fella say in front of me though, his abuse of Phelps is bordering on racist, when I asked him what he thought of the fact he set up 3 tries and made at least one try saving tackle, he said, he's a fu*king Aussie, ill never accept them or Nobby.

I don't think we'd have won without Phelps tonight. Didn't think I'd ever be saying that

He needs a serious rocket up his .

We wouldnt. He was my MOM tbh.

If only it was that easy my vodka drinking friend.

The bloke needs a heart transplant, a new pair of gonads and a backbone.

i think phelps was very good tonight an i think he s not been bad all season mate he gives 100% an i dont think he made a mistake tonight he s been very good at full back agree with u m8

Nothing excellent about it for me, we scraped through by the skin of our teeth, too many mistakes v a good performance from the 18 men from Catalans.

I would agree though, what was excellent was the display of team spirit...... apart from one individual, who shall remain nameless but only seems to be able to score from 1 yard out in the corners when someone puts the ball in his hands as he falls over the line. Put him 5 yards out and not already falling over the line and its more like

We'd do better recruiting Dale Winton

If he was half the player his brother is, he'd be twice as good as he is now.

You will always get c0ckheads

Phelps as showed enough heart and passion and most important Skill to be a wigan player for a few more years IMO

Exactly....if anyone needs to go to S/o its phelps.....thats so obvious a blind man could see it but not nobby!!! He puts a fat lazy lump of 5hyte there who should never get beyond reserve footy. Karl Pryce at stand off.....shows the failings of nobbys tactics doesnt it really!!

For me Phelps to Stand off.....Tomkins Scrum Half.....Tommy Leu Starting hooker....Richards FB...bring ainscough back in...and put the boy with trotters on the bench as thats the best he should get!! Do that and we're starting to look like a team.

Full marks have to go to goulding though tonight...showed he's gonna fight for a place at wigan and take his second chance....excellent second debut....lets hope he continues it and comes back from this loan period in the same way joel did not too long ago!!

Surprised at the EXCELLENT WIN comments though....actually expected to hear the opposite....for me that performance was FAR from excellent....we would have been mullered by leeds or stains by a good margin of 30+ points IMO....far to many errors, not enough possession or field position and generally stuggled with the ball in hand. The game for me was also about as dull as it gets.....to say it was a two pointer it was far from exciting!

Phelps was a bit shakey juggling the ball at the start but more than made up for it, and was my MotM. The Piggy=>Leuluai=>Phelps=>Richards seems to be by far our best attacking move.

However it did pain me to see Pryce crucified before he touched the ball, it must be hard to be a player who is expected to score with ease everytime he is given the ball. A couple of occasions he looked clueless, others he was unfairly dropped in it with suicide passes (eg. the one where he got injured and thousands decided to cheer it

). No way is he a stand off, and he is behind Goulding in the centres, but I still think he could come good, as long as he isn't in the blistering spotlight of his own fans expecting him to fail. Hopefully in a few weeks when they let him play again he will prove himself, but until then him playing is doing more harm than good.

Have you ever thought that he just isn't good enough - no matter what position he plays.