We ve had all the negative from last night but what do you all think of marsh s performance last night .

He was m.o.m out of our players for me .

defensively he is sound but he just doesnt offer anything in attack. sam tomkins was wigans best player last night.

Sam wasn't in my top 3 last night. Marsh would be good in attack if ball went that way But it dose nt seem to go that way

but when it does get to him all he does is put his head down and runs diagonally towards the touchline.i prefer the idea of tomkins at centre and possibly give marsh a go on the wing. Who was your top 3 then? everyone was bad and i only giving it sam because he was at the heart of most things we did good.

Tries hard, but too one dimensional in attack, not enough to give IMO.

I'm not knocking Sam mate , he does what he does every game and I'm not saying marsh is 1 st choice I just think he had a good game last night and stood out I'd of gone for

1) marsh
2) .... Hard choice .. Tommy put him self about
3)......Even harder choice Hansen/Micky Mc . Don't know to be truthful hard choose when we lose like that .

Thought he a good game , he was the only one who chased back(and nearly caught )the Catalan players who scored the interception tries, i was very surprised how fast he is(apparently he was a promising athlete before he went full time at Wigan) , also pleased he scored himself late on , deserves a run in the team

thought hansen had a shocker to be fair, fell off a few tackles but so did most! micky mac tries hard every week and i like how aggresive is but he just doesnt get us about like riddel used to. just no way im giving marsh best player although he didnt do anything wrong just didnt do anything good either. tommy does well when he goes to hooker because his scoots are good and get us on a roll but he is not a class 7 and without deacon or to tomkins at the side of him hes struggling abit!

More pace than Goulding and more effort than most - plays with his head down so will never make a decent centre but would make an excellent winger.

Wonder if we'll get the chance to see Charnley and Marsh swap positions?

Cut his hair or id sell him. Awful barnet.

Huh, you can talk !!!!!!!

not good enough

I think Charnley's the better prospect. Marsh is tiny, and he just tucks his head down and charges at the line. There's nothing else to his attack.

There is a lot more, he just hasn't fully adjusted to SL defences yet. And defensively, he's excellent.

As if someone just said Sam was our best player..... I rate Sam very highly but I thought he was our worst.

I tend to agree. No shortage of effort, but he seemed to spend the whole game on an ice rink.

Im like you Roy, mons haircut

This is clearly an aspect which can be coached and brought into his game. Defence wise he is extremely solid.

I've not been Marsh's biggest fan but I thought he had a decent game last night. Like other posters have said, I think he plays with his head down too much for centre but with his speed I'd like to seem him on the wing. I was unsure about his defence in his first few games but it seems much more solid now!

he scored out first try. give the long ball to pat richards for carmonts try. was the only one who looked like he was trying and didnt make any mistakes. from a very bad team performance how u can say he was our worst player then u have obviously never played a game of rugby in your life!

Maybe it is because he has set such a high standards and he didn't meet those standards....

Watching the game he was too easy to read, far too predictable!

I don't blame him though he is being played in his 2nd best position.

so because he didnt meet his own very high standards he was our worst player? fair enough he probably should be playing stand off especially without deacon and finch at the moment just isnt do it but that doesnt take away the fact that hes still put 100 percent in and was at the heart of everything wigan did good(which wasnt much!) but still he was involved!

He's a winger for mine. Reminds me of Goulding when he played at centre - he NEVER passes.

Id love to see this guy with space in front of him he has got bags of pace to burn.