But he didn't even make contact. It didn't even look like he had any intention. His knee completely missed and it wasn't like he slammed it down, his knee went down slowly. I think Ganson made it u.

He was looked at. Got the same result as Joel.

"Player has hold of ball carrying arm, does not use other arm to grip and lock on, uses body weight to force player onto back, not arm as lever"

I wouldn't mind but did anyone see Buderus' knee deliberately catch Joel in the face after his try? Nothing seen by Mr Ganson of course.

that diskins looked worse than them all

Yes but the rlf couldnt possibly have the champions with another player out of the squad given their terrible injury crisis could they

Having watched the incident on tv i think it was a bit of a silly play from Tomkins, he did try to use his knee in my opinion to probably put his weight on Buderus' calf, something that can be very painful especially if you are 16 stone plus. I do not think it was malicious he was just wanting to let him know he was there, there was a bit of intent in my opinion, but it was a bit half hearted which is why he probably has no case to answer, would have been a very silly play had he fully committed to it and ended up sitting out the Saints game.