There's trouble down South.

If I posted how I feel I would never be allowed back on these boards

and retired

Supporters from that era loved the game for what it is. Apparently you don't fit into this bracket, so do us all a favour and do one.

...just noted that Hull's 'round ball' team have put their coach on 'gardening leave'.....nice term that.

Let us hope that the Chairman will face the fact that Big Mac needs to dig in another garden than The Stoop.

On the facebook groups to get mac out 'Matt Gafa' has joined the cause that must prove something? Links: www.facebook.com/pages/Sack-Mac/ ... 445?ref=ts www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=3 ... 442&ref=ts

On the facebook groups to get mac out 'Matt Gafa' has joined the cause that must prove something? Links: www.facebook.com/pages/Sack-Mac/ ... 445?ref=ts www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=3 ... 442&ref=ts

Jack Graves has joined too.

Not sure if it's a good idea to diss our major sponsor.

Just saw it on FB, and thought it was quite funny. Shamelessly stolen, but you're probably right.

Duly changed.

Paddock the compliance manager!

Stoopy I’m surprised you haven’t reverted to the picture of Mac with OUT scrawled across it. I tried to get my daughter to create something similar whilst I was seething last night and she said some thing like “we don’t have the software”. This from a graphics student! It resulted in an argument! I had to vent my fury somewhere! Why not on a student.

Was considering it actually, but I received something of a backlash for having such a ridiculous opinion.

So is it safe to assume then that despite the trolls opening post, Bacon double cheese is still with us?

I think that conclusion is a reasonable one to reach now, unfortunately.

Ok so all here and on facebook are calling for his head and what ever on a plate..

who then do you want in his place, because lets be honest if he did go you cant say the present set up with the coaches as just as good so its not like there is anyone who step can into is shoes until a decent coach is found.

I said it before that Mac should have got a attacking coach in after that run at the end of last season. we needed someone with knowleadge of present day SL.. The guy i would have liked to see come down to us and work as attacking coach under Mac was mick clarke from barrow if you seen how they play your no why. But i see Wigan have snapped him up to work with their youth and academy.

Just look at BN at Crusaders he knew that it be a big job getting that team up and running with less players and to be honest some they claim wasnt upto SL standard, or that no body else wanted, but he got good coaches in and a round him to give him that help and fighting chance,guys that knew SL and how to get the best out of them. and im sorry to say Mac should have done this before we got this far down the track.

So just who would you like to replace Mac

Im sure we would get 30 quality applications if it was advertised world wide(thats what Catalans got apparently)- There are only 30 (approx) top coaching jobs in the world-NRL, SL and international if you want to include them. Nathan Brown, McGuire were available and have done well. There must be others out there who fancy a crack.

Agreed, we would not be short of responses, and even if Walters gets the spanish archer, there will still be quality coaches available.

It's less a point of "who do the fans want" as that becomes a pointless roll call, it's more a case of who thinks they can improve both our position and our plays and more importantly, who can rebuild what appears to me to be a shattered team with no morale, vision, or confidence to play the sport they love.

Agree fully with what Homer said, I'd also add that the coach should be improving the players we have and I've watched with disappointment as a number of players (in some cases quite young) have simply plateaued with no signs of improvement from year to year.

Having said that I will now contradict myself and launch into "pointless roll call" I've probably already said, but anyway, Jason Taylor seems like a good candidate.

[1 Has some connections, may be able to make some stop gap signings (and we certainly have quota spots open, whether we have the funds is another thing).
[2 Has proved he can coach, has a better winning percentage than Nathan Brown in the NRL. This is with Parramatta (who were a shambles when he took over, not quite as big a shambles as us, but still) and South Sydney.
[3 Slightly more analytical and technically mined in his approach and will no doubt bring some fresh ideas.
[4 Affable character, good with the media (whilst I don't care so much about this if we are winning) it is important to send out the right messages.
[5 Has something to prove and drive (without going into detail over his departure from the Rabbits, I felt he was harshly treated). He's not one of these coaches whose achieved it all at other clubs and whose reputation will not take a dent if he fails with us.

We'd have to sell the club to him, but if we had the finances (and do we have the finances to wait and do nothing?) don't see why he wouldn't at least consider it. Plenty of coaches have returned from the Super League to good jobs in the NRL. It's a far from a career graveyard.

I'm not at all sure about that. There'd be plenty of interest but I can't imagine any coach who knows what he's about taking on this club in its present financial state. The basic squad might have been competitive if injury-free (as they were in the first half of last season), but there's no depth at all, resulting in the team having to be filled up with too many inexperienced young guys, a poor quality loanee and at least one player (Melling) having to play in a pivotal position for which he's not suited.

Classic poisoned chalice.

The print edition of 'The Times' today said that the club 'refused to comment' on rumours that BM had been sacked, which seems a litttle ambiguous to yours truly. Even if he has gone, I wouldn't expect to hear anything before tomorrow at the earliest as things like settlement packages and a temporary replacement have to be worked out.

You would have thought it was now untenable that he could actually stay in the position.

Not sure that I would agree with this.............a young 2nd coach would probably love the opportunity, it's a classic win win for him as he will not get any blame attached for not improving results, but in reality and even with the squad we have, the right man with the right motivational skills will make improvements easily and his CV will be all the better as a result.

Let's see. Hope I'm proved wrong.

If you need any evidence to support Homer's arguement, then think back to the 2004 season, when Rea brought in Rohan Smith as assistant.

Almost overnight we improved our defence both in terms of individual technique and collective organisation. Then within a few weeks we were winning games because we were able to defend a lead and the confidence in the team improved noticeably.

And maybe Smith was telling the players the exact same things Rea was trying telling them. Sometimes it just needs to come from a different voice.

Best news in ages....if the club are refusing to comment then it may be true