So the sending off of Luke O'donnell in 2011 was unjustified how . He came from how far away to punch Mr Bailey. (Who did deserve to be sent off.)

And the sending off in 2012 well even with rose tinted glasses it did look bad live at the game, and if Bailey had done the same tackle on a giants player he would have also walked. Some players are just guilty in the first opinion of the crowd and ref's.

He must hate the video ref system after having a try chalked off at Cas too.

Because O Donnell did not at any time throw a punch at Bailey but let's not let facts get in the way of your ill informed opinion.

And last year live at the game it looked exactly like what actually happened - the Leeds player got his tackle wrong

The ref saw it that way, as did the TJ and it was only when Hardacre (?) clearly was hurt and Sinfield spent ten minutes telling Alibert to send LoD off was any action retroactivly taken

What a load of garbage.









You are David Blunkett and I claim my £5

I have always liked Hudds, but you lot come across as extremely sad & bitter.

Sad and bitter.

Why would we be sad and bitter when our players are clearly better than other teams at doing the bad stuff ? we're obviously better than Leeds/Catalan at shoulder charging and punching because when our guys do it the ref's have to send them off...if other teams did it as good as us they would be sent of too surely ?? so we must be bloody ace at it cos we keep getting men sent off for things other players stay on the field for - in the same games !!

My mistake.

correct

.if other teams did it as good as us they would be sent of too surely ?? so we must be bloody ace at it cos we keep getting men sent off for things other players stay on the field for - in the same games !!

Ok. So at what point in the game Saturday did a Leeds player stand up and start throwing handbags in front of the touchjudge. ERM Never.

Mags tried a few slaps just like Leroy, both up in front of the panel today.

Both teams treated the same.

In LOD's last game for the Giants at Langtree Park he got called over by Silverwood who had been advised he came rushing in to a melee, which LOD said he was no where near it.

Silverwood says well I have a report saying you did, the replays shows that LOD was NO WHERE near the incident.

He got picked out as a trouble maker and was no where near it, same at Headingley, wrongly judged.

Ok lots of fiction from you there:

O’Donnell made contact with Leeds Rhinos’ Ian Kirke in the 16th minute which left the Rhinos second rower on the floor for a further 15 minutes before being stretchered off.

However the situation escalated into a farce after Alibert spoke directly to O’Donnell, and supposedly put the Huddersfield back rower on report. While Kirke was still being treated, Anderson brought off O’Donnell and replaced him with Larne Patrick.

But five minutes later as Kirke was being taken off the field and sent directly to hospital, Alibert consulted with his touch judge and demanded O’Donnell be brought back onto the field and the previous interchange be reversed. He then showed O’Donnell the red card.

It was shown at the panel that it was a clash of heads and not the forearm and LOD was let off. However the rep of the player and the fact the coach tried to remove the player before the incident had been resolved did not help.

So let me get this right LOD was innocent

Yes on this occasion.

Point being some players are classed as guilty due to there previous conduct on the field just like our Mr nice friendly Bailey and not a conspiracy by refs against clubs like the giants like some supporters seem to think.

What a load of absolute rot.

Nowt to do with the fact that the ref saw nothing wrong with the challenge until Sinfield decided he wwas going to tell the Ref to send LOD off because his team mate was injured, therefore in Sir Kevs eyes it must have been foul play !!

He wasn't 'let off' as he had nothing to be let off from.

mcdermott sayin on mcguire 'someone decided to punch him and he was defending himself-and he got a black eye as a result of it'

who punched mcguire before he started throwing?!

Ablett?

ha no he was talking about mcguire

Think he means Leroy, though i dont think Leroy started ...mcguire was giving him some uppercuts in the melee before Leroy clogged him.

yeh thats what i mean, no one threw a punch at mcguire until he threw his. mcdermott talking rubbish

That's the way I read it! Justifying Mcguire hitting Leroy as it was self defence....the bloody clown! McGuire thought someone kneed him in the head threw some at Leroy so Leroy lamped the daft bugger!

First time I have ever seen anyone with three black eyes.