Well yeah murphy or eden wont matter really both good and young.
and well we need to get rid of moore! maybe put lee at hooker!

good and young...but to get us to win a trophy or at least be a top 4 team they will have to improve alot, murphy on his attack and eden on his error rate

i like moore, so does anderson, think he will stay...him and robinson are fine as the hookers for next season

lee may not get another contract, shown some nice touches though, if he does, a possible loose forward for us or back up for the hookers, got some utility player value

IMO players like Tommy Lee and Scott Moore, as handy as they are to have in the squad, should be no where near a starting place if we want to be taken seriously and prove we belong in top 5 again...they are average players at best and will never ever break a game or make us an attacking threat....people will disagree with me but would any of the top 4 or 5 teams have players like this as part of their pivot players??

Eorl and Mullally next year will be great in the line outs!

robinson can start then..moore off the bench.

lee can be a back up player if given another contract...if he goes then im not going to moan about it.

i dont think any top 4/5 team would have eden, grix,gilmour,faalogo(on current form),ferguson(on current form), george (current form),ferres in there team either.

Fa alogo on current form! He's been poor all season the physical size of him is awesome but he certainly hasn't pulled up any trees this year, he should be hurting other teams but seems to be coasting, one of the biggest wastes of money over the last few years

That you tube video of him must have been someone else in disguise because we've seen very little aggression since he came

To the poster that started this thread,this is the team that wants to play mate stop talking crap i know at least 5 on that team that want out so dont type rubbish.

Why do they want out?

Because off speckys like him that posts drivel.

Yes, but why do they [ireally[/i want to go?

On which forum do all the speckies post wisely?

fans turn up week in week out and pay there hard earned to watch there team that gives them the wright to have there say . most of us would flog are grannies to play for the giants .if current players former players now coaching dont like what the fans are saying they should try a normal job if they could get one

This forum is for fans opinions and i am entitled to an opinion......

Que? I don't understand what George has done wrong?

i like him, on current form though he wouldnt be in a top 4/5 side which was the discussion. defence not been good and was awful at hull fc away too.

I'm not suggesting you have a problem with him in general, just trying to understand your point of view on his form. From what I have seen he has been very good and consistent - people get past him when he has been isolated which is due to the men inside him.

Brearley seems to have a thing against wingers though .....bet there was a huge party at his when it was announced David Hodgson was leaving



As Stevo said last night - "he's a winger, winger's are there to do one thing and one thing only - score tries !! "

Personally i think Luke has been one of our better players recently and certainly doesn't deserve criticism.

once again ill state i like luke george...put him in my first choice picks for next season if you look on the topic andersons giant overhaul for next season.

giant daz started the thing about players being in a top 4/5 team...i was just picking the players who i think wouldnt get in... george i picked out along with others going on CURRENT form.

david hodgson can score tries, good finisher. very suspect under the high ball and in defence go against him.

did i ?

Don't listen to stevo. He hasn't got a clue what he's on about. A wingers most important job is getting the team on the front foot. Jermaine is a perfect example at this. Probably the best in super league

Followed closely by Luke George.

true..wingers coming in and taking the ball up strongly and helping the pack out..mcgillvary and george very good at this , strong runners!

Not at Hudds they don't

Quality > Quantity