Am I missing something or do JUST Huddersfield commit penalties?

We keep getting pinged for anything from Holding down, Grapple Tackles, Offsides, High tackles, I could go on.

All the games I have watched both teams have been at it but only Huddersfield getting pinged for majority of them?

Yes alot of people still hold it against us when we finished bottom 3 seasons and never got relegated, but believe me this did us no favours, and was not something the fans wanted.

All I ask for is a fair crack of the whip.

Sort it out RL and get some decent refs on board cos it completely spoils the spectacle.

to be fair , from what i could see tonight all the penalties we conceded were correct and were given deservedly.

our discipline tonight was appaling - there is no excuse for that.

we did have a reputation in 2003 onwards as been a dirty side because we werent skillful enough to win by normal means - maybe to some that reputation is still there

so live with it like most supporters do




whats that got to do with penalties, are you now saying the refs are against you

You are getting pinged for Penalities because you are commiting them.

It's called "winning ugly", and I'd hate to watch you or Quins every week........

You were lucky to have only one sin-binned.......

I didnt think you were as bad as the penalty count reflected.

Our discipline was appalling last night, we deserved to get most if not all of those penalties and he could have given more, however Cas were no angels, yet looking at the penalty count you would think they played very fairly.

Scott Moore and Keith Mason appeared to be the biggest culprits last night. Generally this season Moore has given away far too many soft penalties, he really needs to work on that because I think he is a fantastic player.

I would like to think that the lads will gain alot of confidence from that defensive display because it was superb!

Well done lads!!!!

We got pinged for stuffwe did wrong. Fair enough. Cas didn't, what gives with that eh?

Our discipline wasn't great but Cas were no angels and got the rub last night IMO, bigtime.

did we have the same ref for bulls away aswell ??

Same ref.

Effing Ganson...

we obviously deserved the penalties, but from what i can recall from the bulls game, the same ref penalised us quite correctly but let the other team get away with the same offence, who cares as we won both games anyway

There needs to be consistency. IMO last night we got done for stuff that Cas didn't. Square at marker, in front of the 10m. It works both ways.

thats exactly what every sporting fan wants, CONSISTANCY FROM THE REF, if he is as good/bad for both teams then fans would be happier

as a fan of neither team i thought Castleford had the rub of the green
and i the best team won on the night

I go to watch the Giants and I DO LIVE WITH IT, what I am saying is I should not have to accept it, I have not said we did not deserve to be penalised, just that it needs to be 50/50.

As for refs been against us? I DONT KNOW, any other explanation as why Huddersfield lost the penalty count against Cas 6-0 second half? so Cas never commited one offence?

It's not bitter but we got penalised for interfearing with the marker when, I think it was Mason, picked ferres up before playing the ball (RIGHTLY SO!!), Rangi Chase did exactly the same thing in pushing Wild who was the marker and guess what (NO PENALTY) suprise suprise.

It's a Forum so just thought would see what other fans thought, some agree some disagree, all i want is a bit of 50/50 reffing

Quins won very ugly yesterday

the problem is because we do give a lot of penalties away we get a reputation so maybe the ref's are watching us more closely

Different situation against Warrington

Huddersfield vs Saints 1st game:- i87.servimg.com/u/f87/13/57/68/52/_4550111.jpg Guess what no penalty maybe Browny hasn't introduced grapple tackle, just took leaf out of Potter and Saints book.

Huddersfield vs Saints 1st game:- i87.servimg.com/u/f87/13/57/68/52/_4550111.jpg Guess what no penalty maybe Browny hasn't introduced grapple tackle, just took leaf out of Potter and Saints book.

No consistency, is there.

Watched the replay today and the number of turtles and leg grabs Cas did and weren't penalised for is annoying. We did it, we got pinged. They did, but...

Also watch McGoldrick messing around with Cudjoe near the line after he'd made his break. then Cudjoe does exactly the same but gets 10mins. Maybe Nathan should complain about Ganson like Daniel Anderson did about Smith(I think). Saints never had him again then the first game of the season when Anderson had gone, Saints get Smith.

Happened against Hull too, watched replay on sky when got home and when Aspy was carried into touch the ref had clearly shouted "one" as in 1st tackle (he wasn't tackled but that is another argument).

The Hull players then picked him up and the ref called "play on"? they carried him into touch, now if the ref had not shouted "one" I would have no qualms at all, the problem is he did and Hull shoiuld have been penalised, I guarentee other way round and we would have been pinged.

Need some consistency!! ping us but ping em all or don't ping anyone.

Because you scored of the next play he got away with, ref should have played advantage and after the score, binned RM, at least thats the way i see it.

Think the Millennium Magic weekends show the inconsistency of refereeing up best where you sit through 3 games and each game is penalised differently depending on the ref what one team get away with in one game is penalised in another and vie severs er

has brownie been outspoken