This one will cause some disagreements but just to see what different things most of us see in each player so lets pretend you have to let 5 players go, name the 5 you wouldn't be over bothered to see leave the club(obviously not presuming we have a replacement for those) and 5 definites you would not let go !...1st teamers btw not u19's

This is not an invite to slag other posters off over their decisions btwor demand an explanation on their views just a bit of fun to see if there is a general consensus amongst us or a mixed view !!

[uLeave :[/u
Robinson
Grix
Kopczak
Wood
Fairbank

[uStay[/u
Wardle
McGillvary
Brough
Patrick
Murphy

Remember its a bit of fun, please don't turn it into a slagging match !!

Too soon for this IMO, I'm still tweaking. I will abstain for now!

Go
Broughton
Grix
Robbo
Crabtree
Bailey

Has beens free up some cap

stay
Murphy
Wardle
Conner
Mcgilvery
Mullally

Crabtree a has been lol. Still by far the best forward on the pitch last night.

Crabtree is a very good player but just doesn't have the aggression he needs to be truly great. If he ran harder and had a bit more grit in him he would have been playing for England/GB the last ten years. He is too nice. The greatest props aren't nice; they have that nastiness in them.

We as a side don't have enough nastiness or intelligence. We are dumb and fall for silly tricks instead!

So you 2 don,t have a 5in 5 out opinion then? , just bag a poster, so you,ve had your anonymous stab, now rev up and pass off.

He still made more yards and more tackles than any other forward on the pitch yesterday. He works his socks off every game and for me has another two or three years left yet.

Remember, it's individuals opinions, if you don't agree then that's fine but please don't barrack folk for their's !

Calm down. As I clearly stated I feel it is too close for me to give my opinion on the title of the thread. I've given an opinion on Eorl in response to a bit of a discussion that's going on. No nastiness, no nothing. Just my opinion.

I'm not anonymous. People know who I am. If you don't know me then you will definitely know someone who does. Relax.

Not watched enough of them this year to put a qualified 5 in 5 out but Lunt didn't look interested yesterday. How has he been through the year? Grix is rocks or diamonds and I think Fuey is past his sell by date. I'd put money on Eorl getting in the dream team next year. It's contract up time!

all of them can offer something on their day, some show more than others though but all have good/bad days.

if we could get better replacements then i would let grix, kopczak, fairbank, broughton and johnson go...
as for keeping

murphy
wardle
mcgillvary
patrick
ta'ai

I won't pick I five in five out as it does not serve any purpose. I can have my opinion on any post I want but you won't find me posting personal insults to other posters on this site.
I would be most interested to know why you think we ahold get rid of Crabtree because I would say keeping him is vital and having Huby to help him next year should make a big difference.

I would also say I think Broughton is starting to show some form.

5 to keep - don't want to read they have left are...

Crabtree
Connor
Mcgivallly
wardle
Ferres

....and the 5 that worry me the least...

Kafuski
Fairbanks (unfortunately)
Broughton (we ve not used his potential in our game plans)
Grix (on his day can be good offensively)
Greg Eden (couldn't think of another)

Good thread topic this - really got me and ny son thinking.....

keep-

brough
mcgillvary
crabtree
murphy
cudjoe

leave-

grix
patrick
wood
robinson
fairbank

Keep:
Brough
Murphy
Jerry
Wardle
Ta'ai

Release:
Fairbank
Lunt
Johnson
Wood
Kaufusi

Keep
Bailey
Murphy
Jerry
Wardle
Ta'ai

Release:
Broughton
kopzcak
crabtree
robinson
grix

5 to keep
Mcgillvary
Brough
Wardle
Ferries
Cudjoe (if he can find his 2012 form)

5 out
Kafusi
Johnson
Grix (sorry Scott)
Fairbanks
Kopczak
Kafusi again and again?

Keep
Brough
Taai
Wardle (improvements to come)
Connor(ditto)
Leroy



Out
Fairbank (earning a fair bit for someone not getting a gig)
Could put any of the others in here- depending on who they would be replaced with

Some real contrasts!

Larne Patrick, if used (ie trained and played to his strengths) is one of the best players in SL and would tear it up in the NRL with proper coaching & conditioning. The man runs balls and all. He is as big as a house and fast as a jet plane. He is an x-factor player not being used as he should.

IMO.

To go:
Robinson, Grix, but only if replaced by a top 7 and 1
Kaufusi

Stay:
Murphy, Connor

Good thread, gets you thinking.....

Most gutted if they left;

Brough - on his day, the best half in super league.
Connor - the future. Looks class.
Crabtree - still our best prop.
Ferres - quality.
McGilvary - love watching him play. Mini Prop on a wing.

Least gutted if they left;

Robinson - one of my favourite players. But I think we've seen the best of Luke. Certainly at 7.
Grix - I think we have better options at full back.
Kaufusi - I like him, but I don't think we get enough out of him consistently.
Fairbanks - again, I like him, but he's down the pecking order.
Johnson - still not completely convinced, but admittedly still a baby for his position.

Can`t understand how many would release Robbo. He is always full of energy, and he is very often first man in on the tackle whatever size they are. He puts in some really good passes for tries. Always puts 100% effort in.
If the forwards were doing more Brough and Robbo would excell. What Anderson needs to concentrate on in the forwards is leg drive in the tackle, at the present we are getting pushed back or submitting on contact.

5 to keep
brough
wardle
mulally
murph
ferres

5 to go
kafusi (too few mins and with Huby coming)
grix, (murph and conner pref fb)
fairbank, (Bruno, ferres, taai, Patrick, bailey are all ahead)
Johnson (with out and out props in eorl, koppy, huby, mull do we think he has the same natural build? more likely to be a beefed up 2nd row)
wood (think connor should get in the halves with brough, robbo to go into hooker with lunt which leaves wood out)

KEEP
Brough
Jerry
Murphy
Larne
Ta'ai

GO
Koppy (I know a lot of people won't agree but I have failed to see anything amazing from him iin his two years with us)
Robbo (love the guy and he tries his knockers off but he just isn't good enough anymore)
Lunt (he is a top top class player but I just don't think is heart is at the Giants and it is effecting his performance, very angry to see him laughing at the end of the Catalan game)
Kafusi (don't think he is worth carrying just to wait for the 5 mins a game where he decides to tackle harder)
Grix (I don't think we will ever be a top side with his at FB)
Would also like to say Broughton as well so if it was 6 that would be it