True - but when everyone is fit those two wouldnt be in any Wigan's fans 17 - or coach McGuires either

He seems to be a fan of Tusons though, not quite sure why.

You still said fully fit "squad though"



I also hope he doesn't play Fielden, he rushed Finch back for the Wire game at the start of the year and you could tell he wasn't ready (at least for a game of that magnitude).

1905, I like you. You are almost always on the money (toxic coming from me- I know) and are always balanced. But, what have you been smoking?

I agree it is horses for courses. But the basic fact is Myler would (even with Wigan's dire halfbacks) have scored, i would wager, more than double the tries Lulu would have scored. Would have had a much greater impact on the direction of the games and is, fundamentally, a better 7 than Lulu.

I honestly think these pie trolls are getting worse. Lulu suits Wigan's hooking needs well. But you can not use this 'players work well in their respective teams' line on this debate. Monas/ Roby.. yes. They have polar opposite roles. Myler is better than Lulu in every measurable way, at 7. Myler has clearly shown this year he can lead any team (even without Briers) and can score from anywhere. For god's sake, I never saw Lulu cut out a pass as good as the one to Wood, that sealed the game against an almost fully fit Sts team, a few weeks ago.

oh dear.... you have gone and done it now jd... you do know myler hasn't won a world cup playing at hooker for new zealand dont you?

they will coming out from under their bridges and they will be ROFL and PMSL at you in a minute.

Hmmm.

You're on a wind up, because that post cannot be serious.

So you believe that if Leuluai was English, Myler would be picked at 7 for England before him?

that is a question on McBanana's selection skills. I would pick Myler at 7 and lulu as interchange hooker.

and he'd be lucky to get that spot. Roby is better than him by a long way and regularly plays for 80.

yes because leuluai is a hooker.... if he was english he would be picked as a hooker alongside roby.

is Deacon not your first choice 7 when fit?

So do we, apart from Harrison.

I've already said that I believe Leuluai is a better hooker than he is 7, that doesnt mean Myler is a better 7 than him. Leuluai played 7 for the exiles and ran rings round him.

If Piggy was still playing for Wigan, and we had a straight choice between having Myler at 7 or Leuluai at 7 it would be Tommy every single time.

Why dont you ask some of the Wigan posters who you stated are the only ones that speak sense eh?

just lol

and here in ends me ever replying to you again.

so is deacon your first choice 7 when fit?

Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful

Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful

Massive advantage to Wigan.

Leuluai is like our very own Monas. Decent at 7, and both have won top individual awards in that position in finals, but I'd still pick Myler over both to play at scrum half.

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" WE'LL STILL BEAT 'EM

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" WE'LL STILL BEAT 'EM

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Thats done you a favour he's past it

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Thats done you a favour he's past it

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Gut feeling was he wouldn't make it. Defo hell of alot worse then people thought. COME ON WIRE

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Gut feeling was he wouldn't make it. Defo hell of alot worse then people thought. COME ON WIRE

If your referring to Wigan's first line of defence - then yes your right - he's been [ipassed it[/i for a number of years

Nice to know that CSE grade 5 in tedness has come to good use, at last

Firstly, thank !

But also, I'm not the only person who would have Myler ahead of Thomas. There are multiple examples of people here. Very notable posters.

And, also, Roby is a better player. I admit I was being a little bit tongue in cheek When I said he wouldn't get interchange. I would probably have him in the England team AT HOOKER! No where near 7.

As others have said, isn't Deacon in your halves?

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Morley'll play. Somthing about a 'remarkably resilient character' when he's named in the 19 on Thursday.

Quote ="Forty - Twenty"Morley Out www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... ml&BID=480 King ok Harrison Doubtful'" Morley'll play. Somthing about a 'remarkably resilient character' when he's named in the 19 on Thursday.

Err, no.. it's still 'past'.

So is your mum but that doesn't stop her.

Really.....I would never have guessed - (which is why I put it in [iitalics[/i and with a

at the end )