Me too, but since Ganson is probably on the run from the WI, and Silverwood had to have his mandatory Saints v Wire game at Knowsley Road, he was the only other ref apart from Ian Smith that hadn't had a game this weekend. But since Cummings hates Smith, that's probably why Alibert got the nod.

Joel Tomkins falling on Richie Myler at the DW was far more cynical. Those 2 points we'd have got from the resultant penalty would have got us 2nd in the league. Nasty wiganers.

I cant stand that clown,he sure sh@t himself soon after when L anderson smashed him and he spewed the ball...still say that was the game changing moment when we beat them.

How would we have got the extra 2 points though? wasnt it as he scored under the sticks? so we got the conversion anyway?

Another 2 points. 8 point try, fouled in the act of scoring.

Because, although rare, the referee has the power in those circumstances to award another penalty to be kicked after the conversion has taken place. As the offence was under the sticks, it's a safe bet we'd have scored two more points.

Tomkins has got a caution.

After the Wigan fans reaction to last night and some of the postings on here, Twitter and Facebook, I think that they're not too popular.

Some off the stuff I heard on the Wigan board and Twitter by them last night was absolutley appauling!

Ridiculous decision

Bet a few Wigan fans will be happy that McGuire is out injured.

Can't help but wonder if the same fans wanted Alan Beswick stringing up for saying that he was pleased about the injury that Amos Roberts suffered earlier in the season?

Said it on the McGuire thread, some of them think he deserved an 8 month lay-off with a serious injury

Indeed two faced *****

just had a read on the wigan forum..jesus,what a bunch of evil gits they are..some wish mguire a speedy recovery and some say he deserves all he gets...theres certain players i cant stand but would never wish any injury on them....before this weekend i was split as to which fans i disliked the most..not now theres a clear winner...well done to the decent wigan fans but the rest..

Amos Roberts' injury was in the act of scoring a try, Danny Mcguire's injury was a result of blatant cheating, that's a big difference, that's why I think some Wigan fans are angry. For me, I would have wanted a Wigan player to pull a player back in the same situation and I would never wish an injury on any player especially one which keeps him out for 8 months, I hope he recovers quickly.

Embarrasing they are. Heres one...



Suprise suprise, look who it is.

You know nothing surprises me with wigan fans,
Most teams have a minority of mindless idiots following them,these clowns have a majority following them,,,

They even call most other fans SCUM..

one of the worst posts in RL Fans history..total shocker...what a Pr!ck

Shocking that it's not even the worst post on that thread

It's great to see the wire fans tarring all the Wigan fans with the same brush because of the comments of two morons; odemwingie and king warrior. Both should be ignored by and large.

I would wager it utilises the same principle that all Warrington fans asre scum.

What would you think if Sam Tomkins got injured doing his little trick of trapping the tackler's arm?

You scored as a result of his cheating on Sunday, and I don't see your lot crowing on about him being a cheat. Double standards I'm afraid, even Eddie and Carney pointed it out as blatant cheating.

Some people need big lengthy bans. The irony of it is, they have a few dirty shiithouses in Tomkins J and O'Loughlin.

this odemwinker needs aa ban, absolute disgusting, you should be ashamed of yourself

Wigan fans are worst than Aussies for losing.

Such a bitter bunch, hence the reason for the wigan walk.

I can't believe that Odemwingie hasn't been banned off here yet, I mean I was banned off the Wigan board for posting a laughing emotion in reply to king warriors posts of something along the lines off, Wigan will smash Warrington in the SEMI, yet he comes on here and calls are Wire fans scum. No criticism to our MODS, just abt fobbed off between the contrast in the tollerance from the MODS on the Wire & Wigan boards.

Oh yeah, since being banned about a year ago, I've asked the MOD who banned me, for an explanation and possibly an unban and he has not replied. Typical. See my sig, seems it's not just me...