3 men in the tackle, hold the player up, ref shouts held. Sam Powell comes in as the fourth man, from the side and hits the man just below the knee. How long until this ends a player's career?

Feck em.
Come on kr

12-16 5 mins

I'm not one for defending Wigan, at all (I ing hate them!), but there was nowt up with that Powell tackle. It was at the bend of the knee which is fine, the penalty was for going in after "held" was called.

Cackybumbum's just killed his own man

What I haven't liked about the Pies tonight is the association football style surrounding the ref. they've been at that all night!

that is the funniest thing I have ever seen............

get that into you........

sums the lovers up

Mcilorum is pure filth he absolutely is.............

In the immortal words of Windsor Davies in It Aint Half Hot, Mum

[size=200OH DEAR
WHAT A SHAME
NEVER MIND[/size

Well they've lost and acted like the biggest set of babies I've ever seen, hahaha!

Now that was justice. Not only did Farrell get penalised for the high tackle. He also left a couple of his teeth on McIlorum's elbow. Great result all round.

lol at least he wants to play for the team.

Imagine the how the Hull KR fans feel tonight, they go 2 weeks ago and see a debacle, then come over tonight thanks to a free ticket, and initially hope that there team put up a slightly better performance and then only go and knock em out the cup, PRICELESS!

What will the gorilla do? 'Well done Mick, you've gone into the tackle with your forearm, like I showed you. However, next time can you please plant it on the an opposition player's nose, and not love one of your team mates up.'

Funny way of showing it, by showing acts of thuggery every time, and by poleaxing his own players

Hard men players, I like
Thugs, I don't

He looks like he's trying to get suspended therefore not play for the team.

Aggressive in defence and didn't give a penalty away all game.
Accidental head clash with team mate that happens most weekends in some game.

Yep, total thug.

Fling pooh at other gorillas?
Instill more thuggery into his "charges"
Play the drums along to In The Air Tonight

Even Wigan players were laughing when one of his worst shoulder charges wasn't penalised.

kirk dixon 2 years ago.....yep total thug....and a s"""house

you watching tonights game......

Aggressive tackling in physical game goes wrong and player serves punishment shocker.

Guess Benny Westwood is a thug for breaking Blake Green's cheekbone... nah he's just a hard guy putting his all in. Absolute salt of the Earth our Benny.

No. The referee DIDN''T GIVE a penalty against him, though there were instances where he should have done.
As for the last one. He went in to the tackle to "clatter" the HKR player, but only ended up hurting GingerMinge....retribution.

shame

got it in one what super ben did was wrong and he served his ban for it...has he ever deliberatly smacked any one since..no..mccloride does it week in week out..as you said total thug

Fuck me, Wigan fan in bring up Westwood's punch shocker. You're so predictable it's funny!

The difference between Pies and Wires is that we wouldn't excuse Westwood's act of violence whereas you lot just think anything any Pie does is alright especially if you can find something someone else did wrong at some point as justification that your lad was right to do it too.

McIlorum shoulder charges someone, or upper arms someone, in the neck or head EVERYTIME I see him play (that's not every week to be fair but it's still 100% of the time I see him). Just because the ref doesn't penalise him doesn't mean he's within the rules - here's news for you, he isn't! (and he really isn't!)...It's just weak/poor reffing, just like with the Westwood on Green incident!

And this is from someone who thinks the game needs more heavy hits and less soft run-ins, and the shoulder charge (the legal one below the neck/head) to be re-allowed as I loved it!

Glad you agreed with me in the end

Lol, where did I justify him breaking Kirk Dixon's jaw? I'll never excuse something like that. It seems the difference is you can't actually read...

Another difference is, I would rather reserve the word thug for someone like Cockayne who is fine with kicking a fella in the street in the head multiple times.