i think stevo should take a backseat now...rugby has changed over the years and he is from the old era. We need a fresh take on the game.

Not getting into an arguement for the sake of it JD...but

Balding. I like. She actually does seem interested in our sport....a damn site more than Lynam and Ryder, who looked like they'd rather be caught in a compromising position, in a place where they shouldn't be.

Even with the Wire connection, I'm not keen on Carney. I think he takes himself far too seriously

Arthur. Not too bad

Terry and Baz, all right, but it the eyes of the public at large, they portray themselves as a couple of thick northerners (which they're not). We should be aiming to get away from this stereotype

but your last comment, we need another Holloway type.....NO. He's a c0ck of the first order. Besides, we've allready got one. He's called Garry Schofield, and he's a bigger berk than Holloway, and nobody wants him, bar his crap paper column.

Despite their many faults, Eddie & Stevo aren't that bad. They've moved the game away from the Northern stereotype (some of the sketches on Boots'n'all they did in the mid 90's, made Eddie Waring seem like Jeremy Paxman). It's not particularly broken at the mo'. Dont fix it.

Ian Holloway ain't that bad. He's harmless and i love his outlook and his insight. But, i agree. He might cheapen the sport. Gary Schofield is a loud mouth, far from harmless.

What we can 't argue with is we need someone who knows the sport.

I love Claire. She seems so eager to know about the sport and she has even spoken out to the Kick and clap crowd about the virtues of the beautiful game (shame, she might as well talk to her feet.)

I like the tweedle dee and tweedle dum seperatly. Together they are cringeworthy. But the touchline comments at GF was just enough for me.

Carney know his stuff and we need that. Maybe we could get a Lee Briers or Kevin Sinfield in the next few seasons. They put themselves across well on Superman

Sky should do a fanzone,like they did with the football.

Oh No. Fanzone for football is cringeworthy enough.

Can you imagine the field-day everyone outside our sport would have, seeing a Halifax fan, straight off the Yorkshire moors, coming up against a web footed St Helens fan from Burtonwood (apologies for any offence) on fazone. Not worth thinking about. On second thoughts, it will be like Nick Ross on Crimewatch......"don't have nightmares, do sleep well".

I would be happy to hear Dale Winton on the mic, if it meant Phil Clarke got binned off.