Cummings was right in that they were in front but as no Cas player was waiting to catch the ball then it's not a penalty.
I don't particularly like it though. I think if players are offside they should be actively trying to get onside ie stay out of the 10m area around the ball.

Wouldn't that be the bloke in the Castleford shirt trying to catch it?

I didnt wanna say it but he seems incapable of making a correct decision on his own tonight!!! I like Thaler but he has been poor tonight. Wont be blaming him if we lose though.

Game on Indeed!

Just think if Solomona hadn't had his legitimate try disallowed in the first half.

There was no Cas player trying to catch it. Webster was the closest didn't get near to catching it before Gildart.

Wow Webster managed to do a spear tackle and a chicken wing in one movement. Impressive.

OOOOOOOOOOOOO. Could happen.

But you can't just kick a ball to a player in front of you? I'm not an expert, but surely a player in front of the kicker should not be able to score a try without being offside?

Ah shizen.

This is a problem with the 'on-field decision'. Seems more and more that the VR won't look too hard or long to find something to rule it out if sent up as a try. Likewise if' it's sent up as no try.

The best camera angle of Hardaker's 'double movement' try wasn't shown in the replays until AFTER the decision was made and this isn't the first time that's happened this year.

He can if it goes through an onside players hands first.

His hand is on the line so isn't he out of play?

Jesus how did Sutton ground that before it went dead?

Foot was clearly planted by the time Solomona gripped his collar. Over now!

Can't believe he wasn't going to look at that.

Well, that knock on kills it. Guess Hull will just have to keep winning to open up the gap again

His fingertips were JUST off the dead ball line, good work. Well I didn't see this result coming before kick off

Got over the line enough times to win - one wrongly disallowed and Dorn knocking on with the line at his mercy though. So not too bad.

Some VERY dodgy defence, some dodgy refereeing and conditions that don't suit Cas' style of play (which is why they'll struggle in the playoffs if they get there) mixed in with that...too much for Cas to over come today.

Don't think Wigan have scored 30+ many times this season so the weak defense and one or two poor calls have decided this. Give it to Wigan though they went to Cas and did the job.

Also for all the stick that Matty Smith gets from his own fans I think his kicking game was a big factor in tonight victory.

That Matty Smith is miles away from the Smith of a couple of months ago to be fair. He's improved massively since Williams and now Tomkins have come in.

Wigan are now joint top with a points difference of 0. Barmy.

Point taken. He could be a confidence player. I know it's different positions but Atkins for us was dire last year but this year he's been pretty solid while we've had a strong team out and been winning games. Having those players back has probably help take pressure off.

Think it was a "sympathy decision" by the ref, it looked very much that his wrist had the downward pressure before his fingers touched the line. Glad Wigan won in the end the Sky Commentary just seemed to have this "love in" with Castlefords attacking style totally ignoring the fact that they have the worst defensive points in super league.