I always thought the French Elite was a little behind the Championship, that said my only comparison was Challenge cup games against English teams. E.g Lezignan beat Rochdale, Workington and Whitehaven off the top of my head but Pia and Carcassone got thumped by Fev and Sheffield respectively.

Again, not exactly scientific but the results suggested the top 3/4 of the elite could survive in the championship but would get touched up by the bigger names

Great result Ireland, truly a woo hoo moment!

they can still qualify though for the next 4 nations, the big one will be Scotland v France, they will prob bring in a few players that were missing for the Ireland defeat.

I know it has probably been said a million times on this forum already, but the only way to really make the french international team competitive, is if someone pumps a massive amount of money into the french league to make it a full time professional competition. Whilst I like the Catalans and do think they have a number of good homegrown players, 1 professional team is not a big enough player pool to sustain an international side who can compete at the highest level and they should be competing in France against other full time professional sides.

They could even then have some sort of Heineken Cup style competition every year.

Disagree, nz are competitive without a national pro league. Reality is, like nz, you need around 80-100 players playing in NRL or SL. Getting more French players in the Dragons squad plus bringing in another French club to SL plus more SL and NRL clubs scouting the best 16-20 year old French jnrs will eventually make them competitive. Having 12-15 French players in NRL or so regularly playing is t going to make much difference to the French INternational performances.

Nice one Mable