Personally I don't mind that much. Sure, I may yell a load of abuse at Tomkins when he tries it versus us but I don't mind so much versus anyone else. I like to see a player trying to get an edge. It's up to the refs to notice it.

I've been told plenty of stories of Murphy cheating on the field. I don't think I can recall Shaun Edwards ever standing onside! Andy Gregory was a complete headcase at times. Tomkins is just the latest in a long line of annoying, cheating b'stads who are halfbacks. He's far more entertaining to watch than a goody two shoes.

Not just on the pitch. When he was a coach Murphy once claimed that he was mellowing as he'd only had 3 fights with his players that season.

I think Maguire plays him at FB so he can have a free role in attack, attacking the line whenever he wants. It allows his speed/quickness/skill and speed of thought to shine through - he's often through the gap before teams realise. In my opinion though it's nothing he couldn't do from the halves.

Defensively I think he's very good - he has excellent tackling technique. He's not the best under the high bomb, but that's because he's a half playing at FB. I hope it's not a long term position switch, both for his sake (as playing FB opens him up to more shots) and for England's sake.

Got to admit I'm no fan of Tomkins but when he took off for that last try it was joy to watch. The speed took everybody by surprise.

I believe Maguire sees him as a fullback

him not playing 6 doesnt make him any worse or suggest a lack in his quality. maguire has obviously seen skill in his game that can be better utilised at FB (speed being one) and made what has been a sucessful move. Is Billy Slater less of a player because he isnt playing 6 and dominating the middle?

Madge sees Sam as a full back - he said this when he first joined the club.

Since going to Full back, he has excelled in the role and attacking wise, he is at times unstoppable.

He isnt the safest under the high ball, but he set up 2/3 tries yesterday and scored one himself - Lets just say I wouldnt have anyone else in our number 1 shirt.

Trent Barrett saw it even earlier.

Tomkins has superb balance which with good acceleration makes him very difficult to stop once he gets going. The only option is getting straight up to him which, when he's coming from FB and is 3rd/4th man in the move makes it very difficult.

My mate was saying that he spoke to Chris Tusons mum and dad at MM and they were saying Logan Tomkins will be the best of the 3 of them - which is worrying!

We did hear this re Andy Farrell's twin brothers though. Would be good for the game if its true though just hope he's not a bigger git

Hope Potter was watching that then. St George had he tackled everytime he had the ball. See, it can't be that hard.

In all seriousness it was a very good performance from St George. If only we could produce a player like Morris, outstanding winger.

Just how average did he make Goulding look? Another in a long line of British wingers made to look good by being in a dominant side. I wish he had caught that fairly simple intercept to see how far he got.