He must be pretty dumb to leave us now if it's game time he wants. Moving from a club desperate for props, to join another club whos coach seems completely reluctant to alter his starting 17. It makes no sense, he was practically guaranteed some first team action with us.

I agree y leave if you want game time no offence to the lad but he want be getting any this year at Leeds

Suppose you can't.

Hope this one isn't, although it looks likely now

I mean he will but will be same as ambler and amor young props just dont seem to work at leeds. Could swap him for richard more seen as we are due a small fee? ha

apology accepted (only joking)

yes i agree it does seem a shame, hes been at bulls a few year and now when it looks like he could be in 1st team squad he leaves

It's all a bit of fun on here mate!



And yeah, disappointing but considering we've managed to keep hold of Bateman, Elliot, Donno etc then think we can still feel lucky.

Mason or Sidlow? Who would we rather have?

Neither as good as Nas in my opinion.

fair play to liam if hes taken a chance and gone to rhinos, he may suprise a few and take his chance well.
he wasnt ready last seadom..is he ready now? who knows.

bullscharge we still have nas so its ok they dont need to be the same.

With what we have I think both offer different aspects - sidlow more all action have liked him for a few years and cant understand why he has been out of squad so much, decent hands for a prop,not a bad offload, size and some aggression. Not a world beater but as steady as well get at this stage - Mason a perma tan and a lot of agression,, mongrel in the pack type.
Stats wise one played 16 games and one played 17 - otherwise pretty even sidlow has higher busts, offloads and less penalties whilst about 80 meters more in one game more for mason. When comparing them sidlow (25) has 6 years on mason (31) and has not played in Oz or have a mega ego so would guess sidlow would be cheaper option.
Id take sidlow but realise we do not have a mongrel or enforcer but would prefer to lose this in favour of a more skilled individual been signed.

Sidlow, because of age and value.

Would like Mason bu would be more of a luxury.

I'd take Mason...Having lost Hargreaves, Kopout and In particular Elima we really need someone in the pack that can put it about a little.

Know what you mean but mason gives a lot of penalties away. Think I'd prefer sibbit on balance. Not as nasty but solid enough and younger.

Mason is over a year younger than Sibbit...

meant sidlow

Good bit of business from the Bulls. If he's like the previous McAvoy, you'll be saving a bundle in the cost of hair-products and stylist fees.

so thats why he didnt have a hair out of place after chipping Iestyn...

gotcha! must admit, thought it was weird you'd even thought of Sibbit as playing at prop!

Well, he was certainly big enough..

Wouldnt lose any sleep over it. Never looked outstanding when Ive seen him play in the academy, or look anywhere big enough.

Has this been confirmed yet or is it still just a rumor?

Still a rumor but T&A have said it sounds like hes gone

its not a rumour, hes already there

The reality is that he has moved from a club desperate for props to a club even more desperate for props than the club he's leaving. How long do you think Kylie and JP can keep going?

Signed for Leeds on a 1 year deal to play U19

very

championship rugby here I come!!!!