Pat Richards is garbage. True Mr Average material. Solid I suppose you would say but never ever a threat.

Nothing like stating the obvious I guess!

Quote ="Saddened!"Pat Richards is garbage. True Mr Average material. Solid I suppose you would say but never ever a threat.'" To be picky www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2009 4th best metre maker in the league and a good goal kicker as well which we need. I would accept an average winger if he could kick goals

Quote ="Saddened!"Pat Richards is garbage. True Mr Average material. Solid I suppose you would say but never ever a threat.'" To be picky www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2009 4th best metre maker in the league and a good goal kicker as well which we need. I would accept an average winger if he could kick goals

Apart from scoring 2 trys at the weekend and getting an assist for Leuluais try



Believe me we have some cack players but Richards isn't one of them..........he'd get in 'every' superleague side with ease.

I'd rather have him than either of our wingers, but as meli is quota, swap him thanks

He's average.

So are our wingers but we need a kicker

League top points scorer, 2 years in a row. I would love to know who you class as sh[ii[/it.

You're other 16 players.

Superleague must be less then average then........infact to be fair it is so maybe average is the new top class because thats what Richards looks in this league.

Some people would agree with this the standard of play in this league has gone down, so maybe average is the new class

Thing about Meli is he seemed like he was dragging his feet about coming back to Saints when the season started then when he did he seemed awesome,,but now he has gone back to the player that the opposistion will aim at,,As for Richards,,without a doubt one of the better Aussie players Wigan have signed,,Just look at his stats.

I'd swap Richards for Meli anyday. Not even saying Richards is world class but he is better than Meli.

Heheh.

First he's poop, then garbage, now he's average.



Is he getting better in your estimation, or are most players in SL garbage, or are you just saying random words without really thinking?

Incorrect

Correct

Give over, Hull KR wouldn't have him, they have the best 2 wingers in the world.

We have the two wingers who are doing exactly what we need them to do and they are both English, why would an aussie from a team outside of the play off places get in our team?

Wigan and Pat Richards were 'average' bordering on utterly rubbish today. How did we manage to lose to that dross?

Hopefully we can beat Catalans and draw Wigan. I wouldn't be able to live with seeing them stumble their way to Wembley with performances like that today.

I thought Coley was very good today, not saying wakefield were awesome in defense, but he was the difference for me.

If Andy Coley is the difference, it says an awful lot about the game.

Best thing about it was the campest celebration ever by the rampaging Stuart Fielden.

That was good


I'm not saying Coley is a class player, but he did play well today, and has for a few weeks

Nah. The difference today was that Wakefield are not on form and they had a seriously leaky defence, not to mention some grease on their hands, especially near the tryline. Wigan were lucky to catch them at that stage rather than a few weeks ago when they were firing on all cylinders. In fact, Wigan were lucky on a few counts.

Wakefield did do more to help wigan than themselves

I was a bit taken aback by Coley getting MOM, tbh. He was a presence, but he seemed to make an error every other time he touched the ball.

Difference for me was that Wakey were panicking throughout and trying to score on every play. Their 2nd half try may have given them the lead, but it was also indicative of why they lost - no structure whatsoever, far too much improvisation.

Wigan, on the other hand, did nothing spectacular but just played a more structured and disciplined game (first ten minutes aside), and it was enough to see them home.