I don't care what anyone says but I'm free to say what I think.

And IMO he is just ok and nothing more.

He looks way out of his depth when he played against kiwis and Aussies.

He does a job and nothing more.

So you're basing your opinion on the fact he hasn't stepped up to the plate at international level, when the evidence is there to see that he is a top player at Super League level?

Listen ski, I think he is a ok player and nothing more.

People seem to get carried away when he plays ok.

IMO he was out of this world against Leeds in cup but that's the only game that stands out.

And can I Add that wilkin was 1 of my fave players and I thought he would go on to captain saints but he has stayed at the same level for 2 years now.

I'm intrigued to know where this grudge you appear to have against him has come from...

St Pete is the guy who thinks Daryl Goulding is better than Martin Gleeson and Stephen Wild is better than O Loughlin/Hock

Hes better than all of them bar clough. As for being no better than Bennet, lol just lol

But he had more than an ok game. He is different to every single one of those players you have mentioned in so much as he has a greater "skill set." He gives us more a more dynamic out put, and an extra option.

Gilly is a powerful and fast second rower come centre. Clough is one of the toughest out there, will run balls up all day and tackle for his life. LegoHead offers a good pair of hands and a steady turn of pace through a gap. Bennett offered workrate and dependability.

Wilkin offers, and almost always delivers the extra option. The amount of times he dummy runs not to get the ball, but to get smashed is very unnoticed. As mentioned, this was missing against Wigan at Murrayfield, and why we looked so flat.

Your so funny! I didn't say that.

It was bobbie goulding who I said was another good young player to leave pies. I've never even spoke of daryl goulding. FACT

I also said Wilde was better than phil bailey. FACT

LOL you just mouth off before Reading the FACTS.

We was chatting about young player who Wigan let go who went on to be good like goulding(bobbie) , Wilde, briscoe, long.

I've never ever ever said Wilde is better than hock or lockers because he ain't.

I've never ever said that d goulding is better than gleeson.


That my mate is FACT

Posting fact in block capitals does not make it so...

It does because I know what I said.

Would you have phil bailey or Wilde?

The goulding chat was down to wigan letting bobbie go and bringing martin crompton in to replace andy greg.

Who would you have out of crompton and goulding?

I also said briscoe is better than any full back they brought in since radders left.

Phelps or briscoe?

Get ya facts straight eurogirl before shooting your gob off

Still waiting for you to show me where I said this comment that Wilde is better than o loughlin/hock and where I said daryl goulding is better than gleeson.

Hurry up eurogirl.

You said that the players they let go are better than what they currently have, ergo you think Goulding is better than Gleeson and Wild is better than O Loughlin and Hock

And funnily enough, so are those that disagree with you.

FACT!

Sorry but you got your facts wrong eurogirl.

I said bobbie goulding is better than there scrum half and said Wilde was better than bailey.

No mention of hock, lockers or daryl goulding at all.