I was just replying to this.


and



And to be fair they are two posters who's opinions I respect, but in this case can't quite see the logic in their argument.

We know Puletua has played most of his games at 2nd row and a few at loose forward but he is more than capable of playing prop,come on even you can admit this surely.

Of course he can, but is he one of the top front rowers, that's my point.

I'd have James Graham at Wigan any time, but the other "top three" Puletua, Perry and LMS, no thanks.

That of course is my opinion.

And you are entitled to it,but you are wrong.

In your opinion



Anyone who knows me will tell you that I love good rugby discussion, and will stand my corner. I'm having another one now on the Wigan board wtr International RL and have said that I would give up Wigans Superleague win for an England / GB World Cup win.

So you would choose Andy Coley ( who admittedly had a very good season) over a Kangaroo front rower ?

And I'd have those three over Prescott, Coley, Fielden and O'Carroll



I wouldn't put Puletua as one of the top props in the game, but as impact from the bench as part of a team of four. And whilst I may take individuals from other teams, Peacock, etc, I wouldn't pick a front four from any other SL club before ours.

Im not 100% sure but i would have thought that Tony P played prop more than he played backrow this year.

Ive said it ever since he joined, i feel tony p is a better prop than backrow.

IMO Tony P , Graham, Perry and LMS will be our four props next year.

Biggest game on the planet, England v Australia, with you on that Rougues.

Good on ya for saying that.

Pity more of your fellow countrymen dont feel the same way

I would be more than happy to give up Wigan's win for an England win too!

Seconded!

I doubt there's many who would agree!

I would suggest Tony P has played most of his rugby as a prop this season. Sometimes I realise he's named at 13 to start, but over the 80 minutes plays practically all of the game up the middle, so if you didn't read the team sheet before the game, you'd say he was playing prop.

For me he's a prop at Saints.

Offside Monkey is totally correct.

Saints utilise 13 as an extra prop.

Just been given the Captain roll for England

He must feel like Roy Hodgson.

10/10 brilliant.
I've got tears in my eyes

NRL fan's (my self included) are hoping that the big ranga (what we Aussies call red headed people) ends up playing in the NRL.

We already are hoping more English are coming down

Hang your head in shame and send your passport back to Canberra mate.

There are 3 poor ones in the NRL already... we don't need a 4th

You can't help yourself Barry can you.

If he does go it won't be till 2012. You should enjoy watching him play for Sts whilst you can.

Don't be so presumptuous. He's over there, no doubt having tea with a different NRL club owner every night. One of the things a few clubs will no doubt try for is an early release, knowing Saints won't have a leg to stand on.

Quote ="Barry_McKenzie"Barry McKenzie has learned today James Graham is desperate to be released from his Saint Helens contract a year early and has asked his agent to get him a job with an NRL club. He will certainly be going all out to impress in the grand final and particularly in the 4 nations which can only be good for Saint Helens and England I suppose. I know his people have approached 7 NRL clubs but as of now only one are interested. Ignoring the fact he looks like a milk bottle with ginger hair... is he actually any good? Guess you cant blame him for trying'" www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/ ... 5944370229 As reported by myself back on the 1st of October God it's good to be first with all the breaking news

Quote ="Barry_McKenzie"Barry McKenzie has learned today James Graham is desperate to be released from his Saint Helens contract a year early and has asked his agent to get him a job with an NRL club. He will certainly be going all out to impress in the grand final and particularly in the 4 nations which can only be good for Saint Helens and England I suppose. I know his people have approached 7 NRL clubs but as of now only one are interested. Ignoring the fact he looks like a milk bottle with ginger hair... is he actually any good? Guess you cant blame him for trying'" www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/ ... 5944370229 As reported by myself back on the 1st of October God it's good to be first with all the breaking news