Now I know we as a team have made some mistakes in this game but this guy Perry is about as good as a left handed wa*k

He makes more mistakes than does good

He makes silly decisions and makes too many mistakes

If we wanted a big fatty to try and fill in the gap Graham left then we should have recruited some sumo from Wigan, and even then he'd be better than Perry

Rant over!

He's had a mare, but he's putting the effort in to be fair to him. He's no fatty prop, it's just his composure that needs to be worked on. He could be an outstanding prop if he could cut out the errors and the penalties, he attracts the opposition defenders as he niggles them and gets under their skin, which creates space.

True lol I do have a way with my words when I have a rant but I will say that he is big enough to cause problems but being very realistic I bet he is one of the players who makes the most mistakes in the team if not the highest error count on his own

Plus the errors he makes are terrible, he can cost us games with those errors he makes but it needs to be sorted very quickly!

No, you are right, he was as bad as it could possibly get tonight.

He's been on a decent run but truly had a shocker tonight - the only black mark in the entire pack. He needs to get his head together in the next few weeks - we won't have the general superiority or leeway to get away with his screwups at LP that we did tonight.

Perry was a total liability tonight.

He was a total moron, if he was on for the full 80 we would have lost.

he had a shocker today

He was a bit thick tonight it has to be said, he's a talented player but you would think by now he would have worked out when to let go of the defensive contact. It happens too often to be coincidence.

Wasn't perrys night, nothing went his way but the none play the ball was a shocker, that was pure lazy!

I think last week at Wigan and tonight shows that TP has to play down the middle, he can cause damage there, it takes 3 men to bring him down, little off load and we are away. That's how to make space.

think some you are being kind,he's been awful since being here,tonight just summed him up,and to think he's got another year beggars belief

He's been very unlucky with the injuries just before he came and then when he got here. He's struggled to get fit but he'd started to look much better until tonight.

fair do's with the injuries situ,but because his performances started at 3/10,then upped to 5/10,then tonight ZERO,I cant wait for his contract to end,must be 1 of the highest paid at the club being at test prop when signed,struggling to think of a worse overseas signing recently by any club

When he's up for it, his ability as a prop is there for all to see. Problem is he looks like he can't be d most of the time. Would rather see a young hungry prop instead of him.

My thoughts exactly.

Thought the knock on call against him early on was very harsh,seemed a steal to me,some very stupid moments and needless penalties,he needs to put this game behind him and focus on the next game.

Yes - give me team full of 20 year old unknowns over an experienced first rate Aussie international who's been on a good run of form and has had one bad game any day...

are you serious,experienced yes,first rate questionable,aussie international well even they can make mistakes,good run of form,well i presume you mean he's been average compared to the usual e he's put out,1 bad game

the man has been bleeding the club dry doing a very poor impersonation of a prop forward,lets see which if any nrl club snaps up this aussie international forward when thank god his contract is up next year

Awful tonight, looked like a complete novice. A semi-competent Academy player would've served you better.

Managed the quite impressive feat of being the worst player on the park despite a valiant effort by most of our lot. Single-handedly cancelled out our shocking completion rate for a while.

Agreed. He was shocking. Just like he has been on and off all season.

I'd rather have a young hungry prop over him at the minute

The young lad might actually be d to play the ball and put in a decent days work

And let's get it right, he makes the same amount of mistakes if not more! Than a young un-experienced prop who's not played a full senior game

He had a nightmare. Probably the only Saints player who did.

But yet has been consistently very good for the last 2-3 months. Sia had a mare at the millenium did he not?
Sure he'll be back in a few weeks, still gives some morons a scapegoat & an opportunity to moan about something.

After an extremely slow start he has got better, but last night was a mare. Even to the point where Rush had to hook him off before the ref did.

But we all have bad days and he has had some better ones before this. I'm not in the mood for bagging players to the point of chucking them out after a win in the playoffs. At this point it's get behind the team for me until the season ends. So expect me to ignore everything that's gone before and to be more positive about winning the entire lot. We have played playoff rugby since easter so we are primed for this type of game.

COYS.