I thought that you had to be making an effort to be getting back onside, which is why the Webb one was ruled out because he just stood there and waited for there for the play to caught up with him.

Atkins was just about level with the ptb, nothing like webbs IMO, it was pish poor defence the cost us that try

I think Atkins did just about get back behind the point of the play the ball, it was close but I think he just made it.

You don't have to get behind the play the ball, you just have to be making an effort to do so.

The worst non decision was the punch in Hardaker's face which caused the knock on and led to the possession for Atkin's try.

To level the argument up I'd also say the penalty given which Sinfield kicked to make it 8-6 was ridiculously soft. That 2 points proved crucial as the 8 point gap at the end instead of a 6 point gap made Wire head drop for the final 5 mins.

He was ridiculously poor for both sides

The reason he gave for the pen is ridiculous but watch Morleys tackle on watkins again its a blatant high shot and he pulls him down by his suede so that like many others should have been given.
We could pick apart ANY performance by Silverw##k he just isn't up to it but whilst Cummings is in charge that will never change and as tad says he was p!$h for both teams but more so us as he was at Wigan.

I thought the penalty he gave us was correct actually. A bit unlucky on Harrison's (I think) part, but he didn't clear the ruck enough to allow Watkins to play the ball. I can see why Silverwood gave it for the knee as well, as there is a slight movement of the knee forward toward Watkins which knocks his ball carrying arm as he is attempting to play the ball. I don't think it was a deliberate movement but then Harrison should have cleared the ruck better.

And we cry out for consistency and he did give a penalty for the same thing in the game against Wigan

Pretty sure the rule states that you can't take part in that passage of play if you are offside at the PTB. One of those contradictory rules because if your team kick ahead, you can be involved - giving them 10, kicker going ahead of you etc. If your team keep the ball in hand, you remain offside until the next tackle

Agree the Myler "facial" to Zak was also a major stuff up by Silverwood

Good job we won and made all of this irrelevant

Bet Silverwood gets the WCC tho so we'd beat be well prepared

Look lads; there's almost certainly a thread (cba to check) about why Silverwood 's decisions cost Wire the GF. At least you came out with the trophy.

As the SL season has finished, I've reverted to watching my local amateur side (Crosfields).

In the past three games I have seen a 2 trys disallowed because the ref decided it was scrum attack due to a knock-on by the opposition (and no 2nd knock on anywhere by attackingh team), a try given on the 8th tackle (with the ref confirming there was definitely no 'back to 6' during the set), and a player penalised for 'not playing the ball correctly' whilst he was actually suspended about a foot off the ground by an opposition forward ......... add this to the conversions given/not given because the ref couldn't tell (!) and a total disregard for offside by all teams on whichever is the refs blindside at the play of the ball, and believe me, SL refs aren't as bad as we might think.

I'd love to see a televised game ref'd by one of our lower league amateur refs ..... the Sky knobs would have heart-attacks during replays!

I totally agree - it was a bit of a soft penalty but what option did Silverwood have really? The ball came lose at the PTB through no fault of the attacking player - it would have been either a knock on against Watkins or a penalty against Harrison.

One of the few marginal calls he actually got right. The missed punch on Zak was appalling.

Hall's no try was no more forward than the Wire second try, how Silverwood did not see the hand in Zak's face, and I am sure the headbutt on Sir Kev was deliabrate he moved his head before contact. But there is an issue with Silverwood and Leeds, he appears to give Leeds nothing just remember 2010 WCC

ryan halls knock on..the kick which hit harrison from about 5 yards which resulted in 6 more..funny youve not mentioned them..however best team won

like i said earlier he was appalling for both sides.

Coopers "head high" tackle?

Do you mean the one where Cooper tackled Delaney around his head?

There were also 46 incorrect play the balls between the 2 sides that the ref didn't act on.

I made it 47 but 13 & 24 were by far the worsest ones

His failure to send off the four wire players that attacked Bailey was a shocker.

5

How did he miss 13.........

They had sealed their own fate with that whoopsie.

A moment for us all to treasure. Proper LOL

I'd agree with that interpretation. You mentioned Webb at Odsal but more recently there was one in the St Helens - Warrington QSF the week before the GF.



Don't think it's contradictory. If you are in front of the kicker (but were onside at the PTB) then you can become involved in the play by doing as you say - giving 10. If however you were offside at the PTB before the kick I'd imagine the same 'downtown' rule applies and you have to stay out of the play.

Only we can be moaning when we won the game! There have been some poor ref performances this year, by Silverwood and others, but the GF was NOT one of them.