The Wakefield board have Kyle Amor as their MoM today. Also, Luke Burgess played pretty well this weekend.

So Lunt isn't Buderus Mk2 then? After his debut it seemed a lot of people wanted him signing for life immediately.

Someone I know who actually went to the game said that Ah Van got MoM.
Not checked on the Widnes site to verify , but I have read that McShane put through the kick for Cross to score.
The irony of that made me smile.

That's true, but it could have been any from Hanbury, Cahill, McShane or Cross IMO.

McShane gave us some much needed control and speed around the ruck and we did look a little lost when he went off for a rest.

Interesting that a Widnes fan said he gave them 'plent of zip' at the PTB and he was slated for being too slow at Leeds although everytime he was accused of this it was playing in a team with a beaten pack, It just goes to show how some fans are eager to point the finger at a younger player with limited opportunities rather than seasoned professionals who constantly underperform.

Knee jerking you mean?

I expect more of these threads and no doubts there'll be plenty who point out when he's not been so good.
For me i stand by what i said earlier this could really bite us because imo he's got stacks of potential to be a good 9 for us.

The latest in a series of misjudgements ?

McShane added two Opta try assists to is name for the AH Van and Cross touchdowns. The first for a wide pass play (reminiscent of Cas Away 2011) and the second for a short kick.

I was in the Premier Suite after the Wigan game and it was not good listening how GH was disappeared with the result -

Really hope briges haven't been burnt, McShane at one point was playing really well - hopefully we'll see him again at HQ.

I with tongue firmly in cheeky suggested that Macca would get Cross over for one. Be careful what you wish for.



Nice moment for Cross, celebrated it in a perfect manner, long time coming so enjoy it.

As for macca if he's playing plenty of minutes and games leave him there. Leeds don't want to offer him that at the minute so would much prefer to see him week-in week-out in Super League than in our 20's. Bigger picture.

So, we're writing Lunt off for not living up to a good debut, but at the same time declaring McShane the future after a good debut?

Just checking.

With all due respect, being Widnes' best player is generally an achievement akin to being the world's tallest dwarf.

Worlds tallest d-warf? Still on about Macca then?

Some McShane observations on life at Widnes to read between the lines of: www.widnesvikings.co.uk/article.php?id=8424

Some McShane observations on life at Widnes to read between the lines of: www.widnesvikings.co.uk/article.php?id=8424

Not sure I follow you're drift.



Ouch.

Nice to hear from someone inside the Headingley camp what the current issues really are. Much easier than wading through some of the uninformed waffle that has recently appeared.

For seasoned Leeds watchers I doubt it'll come as any great surprise.

Quote ="MjM"Some McShane observations on life at Widnes to read between the lines of: www.widnesvikings.co.uk/article.php?id=8424'" Better Working Atmosphere, Working Environment, Coaching Setup and Banter between the Players. Says it all really. Leeds could be better if it was MADE better.

Quote ="MjM"Some McShane observations on life at Widnes to read between the lines of: www.widnesvikings.co.uk/article.php?id=8424'" Better Working Atmosphere, Working Environment, Coaching Setup and Banter between the Players. Says it all really. Leeds could be better if it was MADE better.

I'm not sure I follow [iyour[/i drift

Paul is just commenting on how great things are at Widnes. Everything in the garden is rosy there, no probs whatsoever.

Not sure what it's got to do with what's going down on St Michael's Lane?

Yup. When I checked back the first thing I read was the you=#FF0000'r=#FF0000e and thought D'OH ... as you do.
__________

It's clearly just a comment on his new working environment at Widnes and is not in any way shape or form to be interpreted as a comparison to the situation he's temporarily left behind at his parent club.

That's plain to see and anyone who thinks differently is merely mischief making, IMO.

Player power at Leeds whatever next?

I went to watch Broncos vs Widnes on Saturday - one of the lads I coached at 15 and 16 was making his home debut. McShane put some nice kicks in from dummy half, passed OK, didn't run much. He got run over badly a couple of times in defence - flat out buried by the runner. He'll either need to get better at defending, or hidden out of the middle of the defence (as we do with Burrow and something I see happening as teams move to lightweight hookers) or teams will get at him.

Looking at Paul McShane's stats from his first two Widnes Vikings games he's missed 3/71 tackles and has been Widnes's second top tackler in both games so the myth about his tackling continues i guess, The evidence also doesn't seem to suggest "He got run over badly a couple of times in defence" vs London:

McShane vs Huddersfield Giants (34 Tackles & 2 Missed Tackles)
McShane vs London Broncos (37 Tackles & 1 Missed Tackle)

Did you see the game George?

Richie - it appears from his post - did and I'd personally accept his critique of McShane's defensive contribution over the Opta counts which may or may not be accurate in any event.

His tackling since 2011 in leeds colours has been very good. Gets stuck in. Helps when he tackles down middle as is aided with 2nd and 3rd men assisting him to down his man. He holds on for all he's got though. His defence is not an issue at all IMO.

I too would accept Richie's critique over george's reading of stats for the reasons you have said and because I am aware of his coaching credentials.