you a saints fan?

This is the biggest frustration with him. He doesn't need to resort to some of the things he does, and I think he's genuinely disliked by a few of our players because of his behaviour.

Nobody can deny that he's a class apart from anyone else in SL at the moment though.

What was wrong with the JJB tackle and how does it compare to the Cunningham tackle?

Watch it again and then comment again, when it all calmed down tomlins even apologised

Class player no need for that though

Been an age since I posted on here.
Tomkins is arguably the most naturally gifted player in the code at the moment never mind SL. He's that good.
He also knows it. And is told it. A lot. And so he gets away with e that, for example, Bailey would get f***ing crucified for on here and elsewhere.
His kicking out in the first half and the complete c***'s trick tackle on JJB let him down because he doesn't need it.
They were a different class tonight and their support was superb. Easy to take the p*** out of the whole 'Ultras' thing but they're a credit to the club as far as I'm concerned. Walked past them at the same time the team were over there. No stupid, pump-wearing t*ts giving it the large, no taunts, no baiting. Just fans enjoying their team doing well.
Fair play Wigan.

Tomkins - great player, questionable bloke

As I'm currently unable watch it back, why don't you tell me in your own words what he did wrong?

Whether he was totally at fault the technique of three men in the tackle with one deliberately going low to bend the player backwards is highly dangerous....I remember Lima doing a similar thing to Clarkson at Headingley last season.

He is without doubt a class player and tremendously exciting to watch.

He's an exceptional talent. The way he cut through us today reminded me of Mcguire, 9 years ago.

he didnt bend him backwards, he tackled the legs, the 2 players on top bent him backwards. Total over reaction.

McGuire has never been that good. Not ever.

When Tomkins is as dirty and as nasty a grub as Lee Smith, there may be cause to worry about his attitude.

Whether he was totally at fault the technique of three men in the tackle [uCOMMA[/u with one deliberately going low [uCOMMA[/u to bend the player backwards is highly dangerous....I remember Lima doing a similar thing to Clarkson at Headingley last season.

My fault: I should have been more precise with the use of proper punctuation.

You are as boring as Tomkins is good.





#massivedoilum

like I said he didnt bend him backwards he tackled the legs, the players on top bent him backwards. Its not the comma you need its the ability to read

You forgot your apostrophes

but I couldnt care less.......as we scored 50 tonight.

I can't stand Sam 'the gerbil' Tomkins.

It's questionable whether he'd be even a regular starter if he was playing for his boyhood team, Warrington.

Go back and watch him in matches from 8 & 9 years ago and you'll see that he has.

Don't listen to him mate. He disappears like a Fart in the Wind.

but he hasnt to be honest.

Stop being silly.

Lets see how he does in the 2013 World Cup.

Playing behind an Awesome Pack and 2 Aussie/Kiwis Halves is one thing, but I reserve my judgement for if he can transfer this to the international stage.

Then he is a Slice of Bread Boys and Girls.

In order to prevent this thread being turned into some form of schoolyard argument ("Yes he is", "No he isn't!"icon_wink.gif, we'll just have to agree to disagree.

Instead, let us agree on how good Tomkins was tonight.

I respect what Danny has done in the game but no way, even at his peak, was he as good as Tomkins is at the moment.

Mr Swiftcorn will know how much through gritted teeth an admission like that is for me.