Quote ="SmokeyTA"They dont cancel each other out because only one indulges differing valuations.
Whether there is a cap or not if Saints value Roby more than me im not likely to tempt him to leave.
if i do value Roby more than saints, the cap makes it harder for me to tempt him to leave.'"
This last post has finally made your point about the salary cap, make sense.
Up until then, I was with the other dissenters regarding your argument. If everyone has the same money, then surely, we are still on an even playing field.
Our valuations of each player is likely to be fairly consistent, but for a few quid here or there. (back to Kev's quote!!) But, if that 'few quid' becomes 'a lot of quids', then the player has a decision to make. (assuming the player's current club aren't willing to match the offer being made.)