Quote ="tvoc"I know but you were basically saying McGuire 'was' defending between Smith and Sinfield but when it was shown that he clearly wasn't for the tries conceded it became 'oh well he should have been.'
It's all on page 4 of this week's Wigan thread. I put it down to a failure of concise expression not dissimilar to when someone might describe a quad-nation final as a tri-nation final.'"
I'll accept your quad-nation / tri-nation point, You pedant.
However, won't accept the other. Never said such a thing. Saying he "was" defending between Smith and Sinfield was talking about his role. Was he not defending their on other occassions? There was no change from me. It was simply down to the inability of the reader to read properly.