Quote ="rhinoms"This where the insults and childish retorts start.
There's quite a lot of reasonable debate on this thread from both sides of the fence and plenty of reasonable examples to back each argument.
Then we get this drivel from the great pretender
Diskin has been consistently selected in the 17 when everyone is fit and the records show/prove that so you have nothing to back that reasoning.
Who says Buderus can do 80 minutes in a "heartbeat"? the coach certainly doesn't think so and to imply Disko only gets selected on sentiment is bollox of the highest order.
You don't achieve the success this great club of ours has over the last few years on sentiment.
As for his legs been gone for 18 months
His current form isn't brilliant but there's others who aren't A1 at this moment in time either.
Just like last year with Sinfield you resort to writing certain players off and getting into pi$$ing contests when in reality just like he did last year when we ended the season unbeaten WITHOUT Buderus and 1 no9 Diskin will prove his worth.'"
Look stay out of this, its a debate for adults and you are clearly deluded, nothing I have seen dictates Biderus cannot do 80mins, he's clearly the fittest player in the side playing in a game 20% slower than the NRL.
You think Diskin is the player he was, he has been in decline for the last 2 years, instead of trying to carry favour why dont you admit was is clearly on offer when you watch the game!!
Why dont you answer the question as Puig ain't got the minerals, when all the team are fit does Diskin get in the 17?
Simple question even for you.
