good player now with the potential to be a super star he took westerman in paticular appart tonight and without him cas would have won the game.i dont like him the way he as the sulky attitude but good players arnt often liked by many other than the fans of the clubs they play for.

Except Leeds scored 76, you didn't. I think Leeds' attack was marginally better, personally.



In your eyes. There are several youngsters who are catching the eye, and Tomkins is just one of many.



So sh*te we beat you at the JJB/DW/ABC Stadium

Spot on buddy, as a Wigan fan he's a great player for us and whether people think he's got an attitude or not, he's got the playing ability to match it, the players fans should dislike are those who have an attitude and no talent.

I thought that Sam Tomkins had a great game and was the difference between the sides tonight. The Goons just seemed to have an extra gear when needed and most times Tomkins was at the centre of the move when that higher gear was selected.

I don't like this lad at all due to his antics but on this occasion the lad took a clout and he got up an got on with the game, at least give the lad some dues
I always find that if you tend to dislike a player its for a reason and that is he's in your club players faces,
he is a little but you have to admire him as a talent that in time will take the aussies on with the england /gb shirt on

This is my most favourite thread of all time.





Literally couldn't make it up.

BS not fit to clean Dobbos boots

I completly agree, he tried the same with King at the Semi Final and then with Bridge the week later..

The sooner someone brings this lad back down to earth the better!

Its not about jealousy, look at Richie Myler, dont hear about word about him because his attitudes right.. Its when you see a young lad coming into the game with the wrong attitude, come on its the only thing the Saints fans and Wire fans agree on and now it seems the Castleford fans too!

No you do not hear a word about him because he does not beat teams on his own.

This thread is pathetic.

Sargent is a player i would love at Wigan but he targeted Tomkins with a cheap shot and hit him clean. Tomkins took it and i am not surprised it took a bit of time to recover from came back and put in a match winning performance.

Apart from scoring 3 tries not sure what he did to annoy the Cas fans, can somebody please explain?

u cas fans r just idiots,when a big fat forward smacks a kid off the ball,an u lot says its ok,well lets hope u get kick out of the super league,cause u r all a set of w........,u will b replace by widnes, the rugby league dont need scum like u set of b......ds,

Spot on, he's a class act and that class was the difference between the sides.

Well done to the Goons for bringing this young British halfback through the ranks

Jealous much???? You are extremely EXTREMELY pathetic.

Are you 10?

This has nothing to do with the Sarge incident. On 2 occasions in the 2nd half he went down looking for a penalty and pretended to be seriously injured. Personally after all that has happend in the game this year especially at Wakefield I was sickened by this. If a player is injured badly then the time it takes for them to get treatment is critical. If every team has 1 or 2 Tomkins' in their team the game would be stopping every 2 minutes while they found out if they were faking it or not.

Serious injuries will unfortunately happen in our sport, when I look at all the serious injuries I have seen over the years like Crowther for Hull a few years ago who correct me if I am wrong never played at the top level after his injury and to a lesser extent Westerman this year who thankfully wasn't seriously injured Tomkins is an insult to those players who have had their careers cut short by injury.

I can only assume that his antics were not picked up by sky. Sort yourself out Sam, the aussies in the 4 nations will point and laugh at you rolling around on the floor.

I suppose your view on the matter depends on who you support, but I wouldnt mind betting that he doesnt play against the quins.

Penalty count 6-5 the only person doing any conning is you, cant wait for post 59

Caught a few then by the looks of it. My favourite is this one...


Not one but two extremelys, one of them capitalised. Well done, however can I live with myself now...?

And you think [iI'm[/i ten?

Tomkins scored three times( not counting the first which was a free run to the line) the other two were made by pathetic takling attempts by Westerman. Both of the leuli trys if you watch the reply Westerman was also in the frame not doing his tackling.

Westerman had a poor game with regards to defence, but Tomkins was great to watch from a neutral perspective, dont get all the hate for him. I think he's a great talent!

In English?

I think (and I'm knowledgeable on this one) that I'd regard Feka as fat, certainly not Sarge.

Look at your own players, at least Sarge did it in the open (not that clever), Wigan have two players who do this consistently, and sneekily, Coley and O'Loughlin.

With my knowledge of foreign languages, I think I managed to translate

If anything i would say myler does more to win games on his own than tomkins, as myler has a poorer team around him. Tomkins is partnered with a good halfback in looloo, but myler gets stuck with smith who is poor imho.

seems very much like a pointless and sour topic tbh, tomkins demolished us from the back of great forward play i dare say had tomkins and coley not played we probably could have won that game,

Sam tomkins had a great game last night, not sure about 3 world class tries the 1st and 3rd could have been scored by anyone, the 2nd was pretty good though. I'm gunna have another look at the sarge tackle but it did look like he went down like a sack of spuds from a perfectly ok tackle from where i was stood. hope this isnt the start of diving creeping into our game.

to be fair there was nothing ok about it.

id be surprised if sarge plays against quins

Like i say i havent seen the replay yet but to me it just looked like a hard but fair challenge.

And they dont have it on the replay, hopefully be on boots and all.