In my limited historical knowledge, I would go Rudder, but then again, I would like to be as "crap" as him and had his career! Bad timing for us I think.

Matt Whitaker in the recent past seemed to have least natural talent, though then again, he has made a career playing the game - I aint! Then again from the stands I never missed a tackle or dropped a ball!

And an honourable mention to Paul Newlove - this was one of those occasions where every single person knew he was well past it and wouldn't make a serious contribution and we were all right, though he was class before he rolled up at Cas - that said, that's most people's first negative reaction that whoever we sign, so it was going to be proved right sometime!

Ryan Sheridan

Sean McVean

That's the name that sprung to mind for me... well the name didn't so much as spring to mind as the recollection of a player who had 3 appearances and look well out of his depth. The name took a bit of thinking of.

Me too! I still remember the 92 semi final, where he ran 90 metres and then as he got tackled, he 'passed' the ball back 50 metres!

BALLANTYNE what a donkey, even when donkeys were in fashion

Not as many as Wakey, we had six pages of them

Damien Reid
Paul Franze
Paul Newlove
Luke Dyer
Sean Rudder
Ryan Sheridan
Keith Mason
Matthew Whitaker
Ryan Clayton
Sione Faumuina

Grant Edwards and Kyle Warren

Although Sheridan and Rudder are good shouts

Some of the selections so far suggest we need a clear distinction between worst player (based purely on ability) and worst signing (based on actual performance or what their level of ability/inability cost). Ryan Sheridan, Paul Newlove were bad signings wheras Harbrecht appeared to be a bad player and he gets my vote although there are probably worse who I've forgotten.

Tim Spears?

Dwayne Barker(how is he these days anyway?) Matt whittaker (the big strong second row who knows his way to the try line

) Gray Vianne and the loveable Frank Watene are ones from recent memory

Rudder and "chuckles" Greenhill

Lee Crooks! In the first month or so he spent at the club! Two stone overweight and barely avoided dropping it every carry! Did improve quite a bit after that tho!



Elsewhere, Dwayne Chambers!!!!!!!!!!!

Frank watene? he was great for us in nl1, not a sl player but we werent in sl at the time.

Dwayne barker was never bad in the divsion we were in either.

korki, bird, whittaker, franze, rudder for me.

Sean Ryan
Dean Ripley

I remember that. My old man shouting in disbelief coynes made an edging break. Then that pass!

David nelson (rip) wasn't very good. Couldn't believe it when we signed him from you lot!

I don't know he always made plenty of yards!

Just a shame the majority of them were sidewards.

Oh god I forgot about Korkidas, but then you did say worst PLAYER pmsl

Is there a worse forward in the world than Korkidas ?

Plays great for us and did well at Salford, maybe he just hated it at Cas, hard as that is to believe

Never seemed to do to wel at salford whenever i saw him and i've heard penty of trin fans slag him off, been terrible when playing against cas.

Maybe your just kidding yourself

Or maybe he has never seen a decent forward.

Korkidas pmsl

Oh don't get me wrong, Korki will never feature in my list of great props and I shudder when I hear some of my fellow fans do exactly that. In his first spell with us I was one of his biggest critics. However since he rejoined us he's been pretty decent, I'm not going to say he is a legend when IMO he isn't but at the same time I'm not going to slag him off when he in now doing a good job for us just to prove a point. He is now doing a decent job for us and that will do for me.

As for his time at Salford, I remember him being one of the better players in a poor Salford team that got relegated. On can only assume I'm right and this was the reason Cas signed him and so many of you lot nearly wet yourselves with pleasure on hearing the news - remember

That is hugely ironic coming from a Cas fan.

As for your peeing when laughing problem I should seek medical advice old luv.