That comment did make me chuckle. Talk about out of touch.

...and it seems a Worky player has just got a 3 game ban for a high shot on Penky, wasn't Tonks banned for an offence against a Leigh player too, anyone see a pattern here. As for bias, well we are all going to be biased and it is usually either blind bias or informed bias. There is absolutely nothing informed about any fax fan belittling/condoning Mannings THUGGERY.

If you can't win a game by playing rugby, I would suggest you don't bother or at least get rid of your coach

We certainly can see a pattern here. Virtually every game this season which has turned violent has involved Leigh. Funny that, isn't it?

Also, if you can't handle an alternative point of view I suggest you stay on your own forum where everyone will agree with you. Simples!

You have done well to get to "every" game this season for every team in the championship, that's a true fan!

It was a bad incident when you guys were likely to go on and win, for those of you that have played rugby before then you will understand what I mean when I say that contact was easily avoidable, wether Manning wanted to avoid the contact is the debatable point.

You have obviously forgotten, or more likely never even accepted Paul Rowley's declared tactics at the Shay that followed precisely that line.

When Leigh are losing the game by just playing rugby it's okay for them to do whatever is necessary and say "so be it" like he did, he was pleased with himself that it worked to the point of being proud.

Paul Rowley is just as much responsible as anyone, he started it so instead of various Leigh supporters coming on with the insults and telling us what we should and should not be doing concerning the BOD, team and coach take a look at yourselves, but you won't accept anything that negatively finds it's way back to Leigh.

This is exactly the arrogant mentality that I am referring to when you take the high morale ground and lecture others yet fail to apply it in house.

Dane Manning will serve the full 10 games but there should be others punished for their part in what led up to it but they won't.

you expect our board to react to something within 10 weeks ?

I don't need to go to every game, I can read match reports, and I'm only referring to the ones that have turned into fights and had players sent off. 2 against Fax, 1 against Fev and 1 against Leeds to start with.

As regards Dane, why should he avoid contact? It's a contact sport!

stop being difficult, I clearly said "that" contact which relates to "that" tackle during "that" game, your just showing yourself up, he could of pulled out of "that" tackle 3 times over before the contact, yet he didn't and in turn you lost.

He lost you "that " game.

your showing yourself up now.How can you say with any certainty that Halifax would have won
that game without that incident ?

Ridiculous that Dane gets a 10 game ban and the report is wrong anyway. It was a shoulder charge rather than a tackle and the first contact was not with an elbow.
As for the fight pathetic over the top reaction. Rugby League is physical and players lose it sometimes. But how can a couple of punches be the same as dropping a player on his neck and possibly putting him in a wheelchair like Ferres got? The judiciary are so out of touch and are more concerned about PC than doing things with common sense. The crowd and players love a bit of biff. The game has gone too far and made it boring like todays state of origin. If the ref had stopped the niggle from Barlow and others then this incident wouldnt have happened. If the Match officials had things under control then the brawl would not have happened for me. Manning deserves a ban but as said 10 is stupid meanwhile the niggling and even punching in tackles and on the sidelines is ignored...

Well not I'm not wanting to be difficult but.

Are you saying then that Fax would have won the game if Manning had not made that tackle, which by the way would have meant both he and Barlow would still have been on the pitch.

Are you saying Manning's contribution is worth more than Barlow's, I doubt that very much.

How can you say that, it's all conjecture as is the statement he could have pulled out of it 3 times, I played plenty of rugby and once you are committed to the tackle at that speed you can't just stop, Barlow couldn't get out of the way neither of them had time to do anything, it was pass and bang.

As for the term "YOU LOST". Fax lost the game fair and square over the full 80 minutes with everything that went in between I didn't lose anything because I wasn't playing.

Oh and it's "could HAVE pulled out"

Considering appealing the 5 match ban for the first offence. m.halifaxcourier.co.uk/sport/hal ... -1-6681072

Considering appealing the 5 match ban for the first offence. m.halifaxcourier.co.uk/sport/hal ... -1-6681072

IMO the momentum was with Halifax, the fighting just gave Leigh extra adrenalin & energy, so yes I believe you would have won by playing rugby and running us off our feet.

Dane Manning gets 10 match ban

Sam Barlow gets a far less Punishment for punching a player as he is leaving the field

Where is the justice in that


All I can say is its a kangaroo court

have to agree on this point, the leigh lads were starting to look drained and the fight also got the home crowd up again as they had gone a bit flat. Twice in two games where the fight has worked to Leighs advantage I reckon

Correct but a bit misleading, Sam had one charge and Dane had 2, plus Danes previous poor record especially for on field fighting went against him on the second charge

Its completely pointless discussing anything with you, as you have no idea what a fact is. Fact - no one was sent off against Leeds. Fact - one player from each side was sinbinned. Fact - One player was fined (peacock), one player was given sin bin sufficient, no fine and no ban.

So you will now probably start a rumour that the RFL disciplinary panel is biased towards Leigh if you like especially as that isn't a fact.

So why discuss it?

youtu.be/xFjAnprMxi0 slow motion of the tackle.

youtu.be/xFjAnprMxi0 slow motion of the tackle.

Give him an Oscar! He went down like a sack of sheet. RFL have been well conned there.

Think you'll find our tactics at the shay were all legal and no one was harmed .

WHAT? Get washing up done lass.

Correct. I bet the NHS never send an ambulance to the LSV again if it is only for a player who has to have a a brain scan and is detained overnight.

The Doctor at the LSV was conned as were the staff at Salford Hospital.

Littlerich should be running the NHS.Maybe it would save us hard pressed taxpayers a lot of money.

So when a player is sin-binned he stays on the field? No, he is sent off it.

I wasn't aware I was discussing anything with you. I was stating my opinion. If you don't agree with it that's fine. Try the Leigh forum where I'm sure everyone will agree with you.