He's not and he won't ever be, Like I said Webbo has played NRL and Super League for a start. Something Black will only ever dream of doing

Black has played NRL ........, Webster is a Has Been, he was a good player at KR, I and may others will admit that, but hes past it now.

=blue[iEdited by TS[/i

That doesnt mean he is a better player NOW. It means he might have been a better player in the past.

Your argument doesnt actually work

Castleford Wanted him, but he chose to resign with us shows someone thinks he is good enough for SL!!

He's played NRL on his playstation and thats it. Queensland cup is as good as it gets in reality for Mr Black

Whereas Webster has played for Balmain, Paramatta, Hull KR and Hull FC in both countrys premier competitions over 70 times

I agree we must all send our best wishes to Ben it wasn`t all his responsibilitythere were chances we could have took in the first half and didn`t. I feel bad ,but not as bad as Ben must .I think we should show some support for him at the next match.
There are positives to take from this game , one is the crowd so the club will have had a decent payout.Two is, again we had fans from several other clubs there again today I think we are fast becoming other fans second club. There were fans from Cass,Leeds ,Huddersfield and Leigh that I saw.It was a good game for a neutral so they could be back.Widnes may be in the final but you never know they may not make the play-offs, so that`s another positive.

all the attributes ben has, webster is a has been he is nowhere near a better player now ben would wipe the floor with webster these days.

webster was a good player at KR, ben is a top player.

all the main points of rivalry go to ben.

ben black quicker, ben black scores more tries, ben balck is younger, ben black is just better.

Ok, but you'd be in the final if you were led around the park by the Widnes number 7 today

Not as good as hat trick Thackeray though. Chin up.

Oh no we wouldnt. We would have been in the final if we had taken all the chances that we presented ourselves with in the first half and towards the end of the game.

Fair enough, but were is he now, that's right the CHAMPIONSHIP!!
What does that say about him! he's gone down hasn't he

you talk ...... halifax lost the game themselves with a lot of help from the ref

=blue[iEdited by TS[/i

Who?

Be more specific?

Indeed, although he did turn down super league offers to sign for more a multi year deal with Widnes.

amaizing, f'ing superb!!!!!!

He had a cracking game today.

when's he going back

priceless

haha Ben Black



brilliant today everyone has a makes mistakes.

Chin up, Ben our day is still to come.

Fine, so one question. Would you have Ben Black instead of James Webster? I'm not having a go, a serious question that just wants a serious honest answer

erm today, yes :d

Who gives one about Mr.Phillib ?? He can say he'll have Webster all he wants, we'll have Black.


Easy.

he's a Hull KR fan, so his opinion is Nil and Void.

Of course I would, it's not a slate on Black who is a very good player but i'd take Webster everytime. A cracking little player especially at that level

Just out of interest how many times have you seen each player play this year.